Spine - 2026-10-15 - Journal Article
Three-Level Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion (ACDF) is Associated With Higher Rates of Instrumentation Failure and Shorter Time to Reoperation Than One-Level or Two-Level ACDF.
Singh M, Perez-Albea A, Shah I, Jensen M, Daniels AH, Basques BA
Topics
Key Takeaway
Three-level ACDF carries a 25.9× higher hazard of reoperation than one-level ACDF (HR 25.9, 95% CI 2.8–239.8), with instrumentation failure rates of 13% versus 1% and cage subsidence rates of 44% versus 15%.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This retrospective cohort compared perioperative and 1-year outcomes across one-, two-, and three-level ACDFs in 279 patients, using multivariate and Cox regression controlling for age, sex, CCI, osteoporosis, and baseline deformity. Instrumentation failure (1% vs. 4% vs. 13%) and cage subsidence (15% vs. 28% vs. 44%) increased stepwise with fusion levels, and three-level ACDF carried a hazard ratio of 25.9 for reoperation versus one-level. Lordotic correction and PROM improvements were statistically equivalent across all three cohorts.
Key Limitation
The three-level cohort of only 32 patients is severely underpowered, rendering the reoperation hazard ratio statistically unstable and potentially inflated.
Original Abstract
STUDY DESIGN
Retrospective cohort study.
OBJECTIVE
Evaluate the impact of increasing levels of cervical fusion on alignment and outcomes.
BACKGROUND
One-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) adequately restores cervical alignment and offers favorable postoperative outcomes. However, comparative studies following increasing levels of fusion are lacking.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Patients who underwent one-level to three-level ACDFs were identified. Demographics, spinopelvic alignment, and clinical outcomes were compared up to one-year postoperatively. Multivariate regressions, accounting for age, gender, Charlson comorbidity index (CCI), osteoporosis, and baseline cervical deformity were performed to examine the association between levels of ACDF and postoperative outcomes. Cox regression analysis was also performed to evaluate the association between levels of ACDF and time to reoperation.
RESULTS
Among 279 patients (mean age: 54.1 yr, 49% female, mean
CCI
0.6), 110 had one-level, 137 had two-level, and 32 had three-level ACDFs. Perioperatively, estimated blood loss (19.1 vs. 25.3 vs. 33.8 mL) was comparable and procedure time (131.2 vs. 167.9 vs. 225.9 mL) increased with increasing levels of ACDF, with regression analysis revealing higher odds of both in three-level ACDFs ( P <0.05). Postoperatively, instrument failure (1% vs. 4% vs. 13%, P =0.008) and cage subsidence (15% vs. 28% vs. 44%, P =0.001) rates increased with increasing levels of ACDF, with regression analysis showing higher odds of both in three-level ACDFs ( P <0.05). Cox regression revealed a hazards ratio of 1.2 (95% CI=0.5-3.3) for two-level ACDF and 25.9 (95% CI=2.8-239.8) for three-level ACDF in predicting time to reoperation relative to one-level ACDF. Lordotic correction and improvement in PROMs were comparable across cohorts ( P >0.05).
CONCLUSION
Multilevel ACDF yielded comparable improvements in sagittal cervical alignment and PROMs, but was associated with worse in-hospital and out-of-hospital outcomes than single-level ACDF. In addition, it lowered the time to reoperation following the initial procedure. Surgeons should, thus, carefully select operative levels based on clinical and radiographic factors.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Level IV.