<- Back to digest

Spine - 2026-11-15 - Journal Article; Validation Study

Agreement Between the Sanders Maturity Scale and Pelvic Maturity Indicators in Children With Idiopathic Scoliosis: A Validation Study.

Capek V, Knutsson S, Wessberg P, Brisby H, Westin O

prospective cohortLOE IIn = 67N/A

Topics

spinepediatrics
PMID: 41396364DOI: 10.1097/BRS.0000000000005597View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

The Pelvic Maturity Indicators scale demonstrates substantial agreement with the Sanders Maturity Scale (κ=0.69, ρ=0.88) but achieves exact stage concordance in only 51% of cases.

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This validation study assessed agreement between the Pelvic Maturity Indicators (PMI) scale and the Sanders Maturity Scale (SMS) in 67 AIS patients with paired hand and pelvic radiographs obtained within a 3-month interval, rated by four blinded raters. PMI-SMS correlation was strong (ρ=0.88) with substantial pairwise agreement (κ=0.69), though exact stage concordance reached only 51%. Inter-rater reliability was near-perfect for SMS (Krippendorff α=0.96) but only substantial for PMI (α=0.82), with PMI stages 2 and 3 performing best.

Key Limitation

Exact stage concordance of only 51% means clinically consequential misclassification is common, and the study does not report which specific SMS-PMI discordant pairs carry the greatest risk for incorrect bracing or surgical timing decisions.

Original Abstract

STUDY DESIGN

Validation study on the agreement between the Sanders maturity scale (SMS) and the pelvic maturity indicators (PMI) scale.

OBJECTIVE

To validate the PMI concept and assess its reliability.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Reliable assessment of skeletal maturity is essential for the management of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS). The pelvic maturity indicators system (PMI) was developed to link two most commonly used skeletal maturity scales, the Risser sign (RS) and SMS. This study aimed to validate the PMI using a blinded, multi-rater agreement design.

METHODS

Sixty-seven consecutive AIS patients with both hand and pelvic radiographs obtained within a three-month interval were included and evenly distributed across SMS categories. The PMI comprises seven stages observable on pelvic radiographs. Radiographs were anonymized, randomized, and assessed by four raters in one SMS survey and two consecutive PMI surveys. Gold-standard ratings were established for each patient. Agreement between PMI and SMS was analyzed using Spearman rank correlation, Cohen κ, and Krippendorff α to evaluate correlation, pairwise, and multi-rater agreement, respectively.

RESULTS

PMI and SMS demonstrated strong correlation (ρ=0.88; 95% CI: 0.77-0.93) and substantial agreement (κ=0.69; 95% CI: 0.60-0.79). Exact stage concordance was observed in 51% of cases. PMI stages 2, 3, 4, and 7 showed the highest concordance with SMS (100%, 64%, 50%, and 42%, respectively). Inter-rater agreement for SMS and PMI was nearperfect (α=0.96; 95% CI: 0.95-0.97) and substantial (α=0.82; 95% CI: 0.78-0.86), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The PMI is a validated and reliable extension of the Risser sign, demonstrating substantial agreement with SMS. It provides a clinically useful framework linking triradiate cartilage, RS, and SMS grading systems in skeletal maturity assessment.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II.