<- Back to digest

JOA - 2026-10-01 - Journal Article; Observational Study

Establishing Minimal Clinically Important Difference and Substantial Clinical Benefit Thresholds for Objective Gait Metrics After Total Knee Arthroplasty.

Redfern RE, Khan ST, Archibeck MJ, Peters CL, Anderson MB, Piuzzi NS

prospective cohortLOE IIn = 2,1461 year

Topics

arthroplasty
PMID: 41966426DOI: 10.1016/j.arth.2026.03.101View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

In 2,146 TKA patients, the MCID for gait speed was 0.067 m/s and 79% achieved this threshold at one year, yet mean cohort gait speed change was only 0.017 m/s—indicating that meaningful improvement is concentrated in patients with worse preoperative function.

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This secondary analysis of a longitudinal observational cohort used EQ-5D-5L as an anchor with ROC-AUC and Youden's Index to derive MCID and SCB thresholds for five wearable-derived gait metrics in primary TKA patients. MCID thresholds were: step count 1,227 steps, gait speed 0.067 m/s, step length 0.02 m, double support time 0.5%, and walking asymmetry 1%; SCB thresholds were uniformly higher. Patients who met the gait speed MCID had significantly worse preoperative pain, function, and quality of life, suggesting a floor-effect-driven improvement pattern rather than uniform functional gain.

Key Limitation

The anchor-based MCID derivation relies on EQ-5D-5L, a generic instrument with known ceiling effects in arthroplasty populations, which may compress the distribution of 'improved' vs 'not improved' patients and bias threshold estimates.

Original Abstract

BACKGROUND

Assessment of objective gait recovery in patients who are undergoing total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is becoming increasingly prevalent. However, few studies determined minimal clinically important difference (MCID) or substantial clinical benefit (SCB) thresholds in arthroplasty populations for clinical interpretation. This analysis aimed to calculate these values for various gait metrics following TKA.

METHODS

A secondary analysis of a longitudinal observational cohort of patients who underwent primary TKA was performed. Objective gait metrics were collected via wearables and smartphones from preoperatively to one year postoperatively. The EuroQol 5-Dimension 5-Level was completed by 2,146 study patients at preoperative and one year stages and used as the anchor to calculate MCID and SCB of each metric utilizing the receiver operating curve analysis (ROC-AUC) with Youden's Index. Baseline characteristics and outcomes were compared as a function of meeting the gait speed MCID.

RESULTS

The MCID thresholds were step count (1,227 steps), gait speed (0.067 meters per second), step length (0.02 meter), double support time (0.5%), and walking asymmetry (1%). The corresponding thresholds for SCB were step count (1,630 steps), gait speed (0.067 meters per second), step length (0.02 m), double support time (4%), and walking asymmetry (3%). At one year, 79% of patients met the MCID threshold for gait speed (0.067 meters per second). The average change in gait speed across the entire cohort was modest (0.017 ± 0.13 meters per second). Patients who achieved the MCID for gait speed had significantly worse preoperative profiles, including lower function, poorer quality of life, and higher levels of pain, compared to those who did not.

CONCLUSIONS

This study established thresholds for clinical importance and benefit across multiple objective gait metrics, allowing interpretation of their clinical relevance. Clinically meaningful improvements in gait speed after TKA appear smaller than those reported in other musculoskeletal populations yet remain strongly associated with functional recovery and patient satisfaction. These standardized thresholds support integration of digital gait assessment into postoperative monitoring and individualized rehabilitation strategies.