JOT - 2026-05-05 - Journal Article
Do computerized tomography images influence surgeons' estimates of posterior tilt angle or treatment preference for minimally displaced femoral neck fractures?
Shabani S, O'Hara NN, Ross RC, Wier J, Gasho J, Sprague S, Slobogean GP, Patterson JT
Topics
Key Takeaway
Adding axial CT to radiographs increased surgeons' posterior tilt estimates by 6° and shifted treatment preference 20% toward arthroplasty for minimally displaced femoral neck fractures.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This survey study asked 69 attending surgeons to estimate posterior tilt and state treatment preference (fixation vs. arthroplasty) for 10 minimally displaced femoral neck fractures first from AP/lateral radiographs, then after viewing axial CT images of the same cases. CT viewing increased posterior tilt estimates by a mean of 6° (95% CI 4–7°, p<0.0001) and shifted treatment preference 20% toward arthroplasty (95% CI 14–26°, p<0.0001). These shifts occurred across a convenience sample of surgeons from North America, South America, and Europe.
Key Limitation
The study measures surgeon intent rather than actual operative decisions or patient outcomes, so whether the CT-driven shift toward arthroplasty improves or worsens clinical results remains unknown.
Original Abstract
OBJECTIVES
To determine if axial computerized tomography (CT) images compared with radiographs of minimally displaced femoral neck fractures in older adults change surgeons' estimates of posterior tilt or treatment preference for internal fixation versus arthroplasty.
METHODS
Design: A survey was developed from the clinical vignettes, injury radiographs of anteroposterior (AP) pelvis and lateral hip, and CT pelvis axial images of 10 patients randomly selected from 50 patients with minimally displaced femoral neck fractures enrolled in a clinical trial. Survey respondents estimated femoral neck fracture posterior tilt angle (0-90°) and stated their treatment preference on a scale of 100% for internal fixation to 100% for arthroplasty based on the radiographs, then again after viewing the CT images of the same patient.
SETTING
The survey was administered electronically using REDCap and distributed by email between 15 June and 15 July 2025.
PATIENT SELECTION CRITERIA
The survey was distributed to a convenience sample of attending orthopaedic surgeons with hip fracture call experience nonrandomly selected from email contacts of colleagues, acquaintances, and extramural research collaborators located in North America, South America, and Europe. Neither fellowship training nor practice setting were requirements for participation.
OUTCOME MEASURES AND COMPARISONS
The mean differences in posterior tilt estimates and treatment preferences between radiographs and CT were estimated using linear mixed-effects models.
RESULTS
Complete survey responses were received from 69 of 98 participants (70.4% response rate). Posterior tilt estimates were 6° greater based on CT versus radiographs (95% confidence interval [CI], 4-7°; p<0.0001). CT images significantly changed treatment preferences by 20% more in favor of arthroplasty (95% CI, 14-26%; p<0.0001).
CONCLUSIONS
Axial CT images significantly changed orthopaedic surgeons' estimates of posterior tilt and treatment preferences in favor of arthroplasty for minimally displaced femoral neck fractures compared to radiographs.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Prognostic Level V.