<- Back to digest

JAAOS - 2026-10-15 - Journal Article

Remain-In or Opt-Out: An Economic Evaluation of Medicare Opt-Outs in Orthopaedic Surgery.

Lee B, Levin AS

retrospective cohortLOE IIIn = 341 opted-out orthopaedic surgeons; Medicare enrollment and zip-code level data analyzed nationally2002–2025 (retrospective longitudinal analysis)

Topics

general
PMID: 42159374DOI: 10.5435/JAAOS-D-25-01405View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

As of January 2025, 341 orthopaedic surgeons (1.7% of Medicare-enrolled) have opted out of Medicare, with annual opt-outs rising from 0.3 to 32.0 per year between 2002–2004 and 2022–2024, concentrated in areas where charge-payment ratios are 18.3% higher than non-opt-out regions.

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This study quantified the prevalence, geographic distribution, and economic drivers of Medicare opt-outs among orthopaedic surgeons using CMS data as of January 2025. Opt-outs were 107-fold higher annually in 2022–2024 versus 2002–2004, concentrated in high-cost regions (70% in areas with regional price parities >110% national average). Opt-out zip codes had 612 more Medicare orthopaedic beneficiaries per zip code than non-opt-out areas (P<0.0001) and a Medicare-eligible population proportion 18.1% above the national rate, indicating disproportionate access impact on high-need elderly populations.

Key Limitation

The ecological design using zip-code aggregates cannot determine whether opt-out surgeons are being replaced by non-opt-out surgeons locally, potentially overestimating the net access deficit.

Original Abstract

BACKGROUND

Medicare reimbursements for orthopaedic surgeries have consistently declined over past decades, raising concerns about surgeons opting out of Medicare and reducing coverage for older adults. However, little is known about this phenomenon.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective evaluation of orthopaedic surgeon Medicare opt-outs as of January 2025. We analyzed charge-payment ratios of orthopaedic surgeries performed in areas with versus without opt-outs and examined the 3-year moving averages and population demographics for areas with opt-outs.

RESULTS

As of January 2025, 341 orthopaedic surgeons have opted out of Medicare, representing 0.7% of all opted-out practitioners and 1.7% of 2022 Medicare-enrolled orthopaedic surgeons. The median charge-payment ratio for all orthopaedic surgeries is 18.3% higher in areas with these opt-outs compared with those without (95% confidence interval [CI], 11.7% to 30.1%; P < 0.0001) and 34.5% higher for joint arthroplasty and reconstruction surgeries (95% CI, 9.2% to 51.9%; P = 0.0003). These opt-outs primarily occurred in high-cost regions, with approximately 70% of surgeons practicing in areas with regional price parities greater than 110% of the national average. Consequently, Medicare opt-outs by orthopaedic surgeons have risen from 0.3 to 32.0 annually from 2002-2004 to 2022-2024. In 2022, there were 958 reported Medicare beneficiaries of orthopaedic surgeries per zip code in areas with opt-outs, 612 higher than in areas without opt-outs (95% CI, 277 to 629; P < 0.0001). The median proportion of Medicare-eligible individuals by age in areas with opt-outs is 35.8%, 18.1% higher than the national rate (95% CI, 16.3% to 19.3%; P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Orthopaedic surgeons practicing in high-cost and relatively lower reimbursed areas are increasingly opting out of Medicare, disproportionately affecting older adults and higher need areas.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

These results suggest that correcting declining Medicare surgery reimbursements is critical to minimize coverage lapses for a growing older adult population, which is an important issue in orthopaedic surgery.