JOT - 2026-11-01 - Journal Article; Comparative Study
Comparative Analysis of Nail Plate Combination Over Alternative Fixation Constructs in Low-Energy Distal Femur Fractures: Recovery of Ambulatory Status and Outcomes.
Pereira DE, Rust B, Barton D, Eggebrecht Z, Wilson JL, Obey MR, McAndrew CM, Berkes MB
Topics
Key Takeaway
Nail-plate combination (NPC) achieved lower ambulatory impairment scores versus lateral locking plate at 3 and 6 weeks (−0.8 and −1.1 Koval points, respectively) and versus both LLP and rIMN at 3 and 6 months, with 6-month mortality of 9% vs. 19% for rIMN (P=0.04) in low-energy distal femur fractures.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This single-center retrospective cohort compared NPC (n=189), lateral locking plate (n=118), retrograde IMN (n=79), and dual-plate (n=18) fixation for low-energy distal femur fractures (OTA/AO 33A/C, Su 1–3) using Koval Walking Score as the primary outcome. NPC demonstrated statistically lower ambulatory impairment scores versus LLP at 3 and 6 weeks and versus both LLP and rIMN at 3 and 6 months, with differences surviving Bonferroni correction at 3 and 6 weeks. Six-month mortality favored NPC over rIMN (9% vs. 19%, P=0.04), while radiographic union rates were comparable across all constructs (P=0.104).
Key Limitation
Construct selection was not randomized and was driven by fracture complexity (NPC preferentially used for Su 2–3), making it impossible to isolate implant effect from fracture severity effect on ambulatory and mortality outcomes.
Original Abstract
OBJECTIVES
To compare ambulatory status, union, mortality, and operative complications in patients with distal femur fracture treated with the nail plate combination (NPC) and alternative fixation constructs.
DESIGN
Retrospective Cohort Study.
SETTING
Single Level 1, tertiary referral Academic center.
PATIENT SELECTION CRITERIA
This study included adults with a low-energy distal femur fracture (OTA/AO33A/C and Su 1-3) that received ORIF within 2018-2024. Exclusions were pathologic fractures, antegrade intramedullary devices, and baseline nonambulators (from ambulatory status evaluation only).
OUTCOME MEASURES AND COMPARISONS
The primary outcome was ambulatory status at postoperative intervals using Koval-Walking-Score. Secondary outcomes included radiographic union, mortality, and reoperation.
RESULTS
A total of 404 patients with a low-energy distal femur fracture were included, with 342 included for mobility analysis. Fixation constructs included 189 NPC (mean age 75.0 ± 10.2, 83.1% female), 118 lateral locking plate (LLP) (mean age 73.4 ± 10.2; 76.3% female), 79 retrograde intramedullary nail (rIMN) (mean age 73.7 ± 11.1, 74.7% female), and 18 dual plate combination (mean age 74.6 ± 10.9, 83.3% female) (age P = 0.567, sex P = 0.701). NPC was more frequently selected for Su 2 (56.2%) and Su 3 (65.9%) ( P = 0.001). NPC demonstrated lower average ambulatory impairment score over
LLP
3 weeks (-0.8; P = 0.002), 6 weeks (-1.1; P < 0.001), and both LLP and rIMN at 3 months (-0.9/-0.8; P = 0.049/0.013) and 6 months (-0.9/-0.8; P = 0.043/0.021). After Bonferroni correction to account for multiple testing, post hoc pairwise comparisons showed that NPC ambulation scores remained lower at 3 and 6 weeks (-0.8, P = 0.024; -1.1, P < 0.001). Six-month mortality was lower in NPC than rIMN (9% vs. 19%; P = 0.04). Dual plate combination showed higher infection (22.2%; P = 0.012), wound dehiscence (11.1%; P = 0.013), and drainage (5.6%; P < 0.001); although sample size limited analysis. Radiographic union was comparable (36.3% vs. 52.9% vs. 39.6% vs. 54.5%, P = 0.104).
CONCLUSIONS
In this study, NPC was associated with superior ambulatory recovery rates to preinjury status over single-implant constructs and improved mortality rates over rIMN. Thus, NPC represented a reliable construct for early ambulation and recovery in these injuries.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.