Arthroscopy - 2026-06-28 - Journal Article
Female Patients Exhibit a Narrower Glenoid Rim and Lower Bone Density in the Anteroinferior Quadrant Compared With Male Patients.
Geuskens W, Lakdawala HA, Jaspers M, Doyle T, Rasidovic D, Verborgt O, Flanagan O, Hurley E, Mullett H
Topics
Key Takeaway
Female patients have a significantly narrower glenoid rim (neck-to-face ratio, p<0.001) and lower anteroinferior quadrant bone density (272.5 vs. 303.0 HU, p=0.009) compared to males, independent of instability status.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This retrospective single-institution study evaluated sex-based differences in glenoid rim morphology via MRI (204 patients, instability vs. uninjured cohorts) and bone density via CT Hounsfield units in 102 uninjured subjects. Female patients demonstrated a significantly narrower glenoid neck-to-face ratio in both instability and uninjured cohorts (p<0.001 each), with no difference between instability and uninjured subjects of the same sex (p=0.22, p=0.43). Anteroinferior quadrant bone density was 11.7% lower in females (272.5 vs. 303.0 HU, p=0.009), while mid-anterior density showed no sex-based difference (p=0.65).
Key Limitation
The bone density analysis was performed exclusively in uninjured subjects, so whether instability-related bone loss further compounds the sex-based HU deficit at the anteroinferior quadrant remains unknown.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
The purpose of this study was to evaluate sex-based differences in glenoid rim morphology and bone density relevant to arthroscopic Bankart repair.
METHODS
This retrospective study assessed differences in glenoid rim morphology between sexes in patients with shoulder instability and uninjured control subjects who underwent a magnetic resonance imaging scan of the shoulder at a single institution between 2014 and 2023. The glenoid neck-to-face ratio was calculated to compare differences in steepness of the glenoid neck. Bone density was analyzed in a separate cohort of uninjured subjects using computed tomography scans, with Hounsfield units measured in the anteroinferior (4-6 o'clock) quadrant and the mid-anterior (3 o'clock) region.
RESULTS
A total of 204 patients (51 shoulders per cohort) were included for the glenoid morphology analysis, and a separate group of 102 uninjured patients was included for bone density evaluation. The neck-to-face ratio differed significantly between male patients and female patients in both the instability cohort (P < .001) and the uninjured cohort (P < .001). There were no significant differences between instability and uninjured cohorts of the same sex (P = .22 and P = .43). Bone density in the anteroinferior quadrant of the glenoid was significantly lower in female patients (median: 272.5 HU) compared with male patients (median: 303.0 HU; P = .009), whereas the mid-anterior region showed no significant differences (P = .65).
CONCLUSIONS
Female patients exhibit a significantly narrower glenoid rim compared with male patients, with no differences between instability and uninjured subjects of the same sex. Bone density at the anteroinferior quadrant (4-6 o'clock) was also lower in female patients, whereas no difference was observed at the mid-anterior region (3 o'clock).
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Level III, retrospective comparative study.