International Orthopaedics - 2026-07-10 - Journal Article
Patient selection refines total hip arthroplasty free survival after hip arthroscopy: an eighteen year, one thousand and fifty one hip cohort study.
Seijas R, Vázquez M, Laiz P, Escutia L, Barastegui D, Ayestarán I, García-Bordes L, Álvarez-Díaz P, Cugat R
Topics
Key Takeaway
ALAD grade (HR 2.59) and Tönnis grade (HR 2.13) were the dominant independent predictors of THA conversion after hip arthroscopy, and era-level improvements in 5-year THA-free survival (83.3% Era II → 95.9% Era IV) were fully explained by stricter patient selection rather than technical advances.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study asked whether improving THA-free survival across an 18-year, single-surgeon hip arthroscopy series reflected better patient selection or technical evolution. A consecutive series of 1,051 FAI hips (Tönnis 0–2) was stratified into four eras; THA conversion occurred in 83 hips (7.9%), with 5-year THA-free survival ranging from 83.3% (Era II, peak Tönnis ≥2 prevalence 29.5%) to 95.9% (Era IV, Tönnis ≥2 prevalence 10.0%). On multivariable Cox regression, era hazard ratios became non-significant (p>0.19) after adjustment for ALAD grade (HR 2.59), Tönnis grade (HR 2.13), and age (HR 1.06/year), confirming that outcome improvement was driven by selection rather than technique.
Key Limitation
Single-surgeon, single-center design with no internal model validation limits generalizability and raises concern for overfitting of the Cox model (C-index 0.911 unvalidated).
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
To determine whether improvement in THA-free survival across an 18-year hip arthroscopy series is attributable to progressive exclusion of high-risk patient profiles or to era-specific technical advances, and to identify the radiological selection thresholds most strongly associated with this improvement.
METHODS
Retrospective analysis of a prospectively maintained single-surgeon database. A consecutive series of 1,051 hips operated on for FAI (2007-2025; Tönnis grades 0 to 2) was stratified into four surgical eras. The primary outcome was THA conversion. THA-free survival was estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method; predictors of conversion were identified by multivariable Cox proportional hazards regression.
RESULTS
Eighty-three hips (7.9%) underwent THA conversion over a median follow-up of 53.6 months (5,939 patient-years). Five-year THA-free survival was 91.4% (95% CI 89.3-93.1%) overall and differed significantly across eras (log-rank p < 0.0001). Era II (2012-2015) had the lowest five-year survival (83.3%; 95% CI: 75.5-86.1%), corresponding to the peak prevalence of Tönnis grade ≥ 2 (29.5%) in the entire series. Progressive changes in radiological selection criteria were accompanied by a reduction in severe ALAD lesions identified intraoperatively. The prevalence of Tönnis grade ≥ 2 declined from 29.5% to 10.0% across eras. On multivariable analysis, ALAD grade (HR 2.59; 95% CI 1.58-4.27; p < 0.001), Tönnis grade (HR 2.13; 1.24-3.66; p = 0.006) and age (HR 1.06/year; p < 0.001) were independent predictors of THA conversion; era hazard ratios were non-significant after adjustment for these variables (p > 0.19). The five-year estimate for Era IV (95.9%) should be interpreted with caution given the limited follow-up in this cohort (median 30.8 months). Apparent C-index: 0.911 (95% CI 0.882-0.940); no internal validation was performed.
CONCLUSION
Improvement in THA-free survival over 18 years was closely associated with the progressive reduction in the proportion of operated patients with Tönnis grade ≥ 2. Although technical evolution occurred concurrently, era effects were substantially attenuated after adjustment for patient selection variables. Tönnis grade functions as the primary pre-operative selection variable; ALAD grade, identified intraoperatively, had the highest adjusted hazard ratio for THA conversion and reflects the consequences of pre-operative selection. These findings support the importance of pre-operative radiological selection-particularly Tönnis grade-when interpreting THA conversion rates across institutions and historical surgical series.