Arthroscopy - 2026-11-01 - Journal Article
Hill-Sachs Lesion Size Is Not Associated With Chronicity of Anterior Shoulder Instability But Is Larger After Anterior Shoulder Dislocation Versus Subluxation.
Dadoo S, Lin RT, Williams TC, Gilbert R, Vargas L, Jaspers M, Popchak A, Lesniak BP, Rodosky M, Hughes JD, Lin A
Topics
Key Takeaway
Glenohumeral dislocation (vs. subluxation) predicts larger Hill-Sachs lesion area (201.9 vs. 150.7 mm²), while chronicity >6 months predicts distance-to-dislocation <8 mm (OR 2.2) but does not affect lesion size.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study examined whether chronicity, event number, and instability type (dislocation vs. subluxation) predict Hill-Sachs lesion (HSL) size on MRI in 255 patients undergoing arthroscopic Bankart repair. Acute vs. chronic instability showed no difference in HSL width, length, or area (201.6 vs. 215.7 mm²; P=.154), but dislocation produced larger HSL area than subluxation (201.9 vs. 150.7 mm²; P=.012). Multivariable regression identified female sex and dislocation as independent predictors of smaller and larger HSL area, respectively, while chronicity predicted distance-to-dislocation <8 mm (OR 2.2).
Key Limitation
Exclusion of patients with glenoid bone loss >20% limits generalizability to the highest-risk instability cohort where Hill-Sachs engagement and off-track classification are most consequential.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
To evaluate preoperative factors associated with Hill-Sachs lesion (HSL) size at the time of imaging, including chronicity, number, and type (dislocation vs subluxation) of prior anterior shoulder instability events.
METHODS
All patients undergoing arthroscopic Bankart repair between 2007 and 2023 were retrospectively reviewed. Exclusion criteria included age <14 years, revision surgery, glenoid bone loss >20%, unavailable magnetic resonance imaging, and lack of HSL. Patients were grouped based on chronicity of instability (acute ≤6 months vs chronic >6 months), 1 versus multiple prior instability events, and dislocation versus subluxation. HSL width and length were measured on axial and sagittal magnetic resonance imaging, respectively. HSL area (recorded in mm 2 ) was calculated as HSL width time length. Imaging variables were compared between groups, and multivariable regression evaluated predictors of larger HSL area and smaller distance to dislocation (DTD). Significance was set to P < .050.
RESULTS
After exclusion criteria, 255 patients (age: 22 ± 8 years; 24% female) were included for analysis. There was no association between acute versus chronic anterior shoulder instability and HSL width (11.6 vs 12.4 mm; P = .196), length (16.4 vs 16.7 mm; P = .521), or area (201.6 vs 215.7 mm 2 ; P = .154). Patients who experienced dislocation versus subluxation had larger HSL length (16.7 vs 13.4 mm; P < .001) and HSL area (201.9 vs 150.7mm 2 ; P = .012). Female sex (B: -74.5; P = .001) and glenohumeral dislocation (B: 49.5; P = .037) were predictors of smaller and larger HSL area, respectively, whereas chronic anterior shoulder instability was a predictor of DTD < 8 mm (odds ratio: 2.2; P = .008).
CONCLUSIONS
Chronic anterior shoulder instability did not influence HSL size at the time of imaging but was found to be a predictor of DTD < 8 mm. Conversely, glenohumeral dislocation was a significant predictor of larger HSL area. This indicates that HSL size may be influenced more by type of instability event, whereas DTD may be more influenced by chronicity of anterior shoulder instability.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Level III, retrospective cohort study.