Arthroscopy - 2026-09-29 - Journal Article; Review
All-Inside Medial Meniscus Root Repair Improves Function With Results Comparable to Tibial Pullout Method, but Both Methods Fail to Correct Extrusion: A Systematic Review of Clinical and Biomechanical Studies.
Vosoughi F, Menbari Oskouie I, Entezari A, Torkamanzadeh P, Taghva Nakhjiri M
Topics
Key Takeaway
All-inside medial meniscus root repair achieves Lysholm score improvements of 20.8–38.2 points and complete healing rates of 64.7–67.8%, but neither all-inside nor transtibial pullout repair consistently corrects meniscal extrusion (postoperative extrusion range: -2.2 to -0.6 mm vs. -1.9 to +0.1 mm, respectively).
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This systematic review synthesized clinical and biomechanical data on all-inside versus transtibial pullout repair for medial posterior meniscal root tears across 12 studies through August 2025. Both techniques produced significant improvements in patient-reported outcomes, with Lysholm gains of 20.8–38.2 (all-inside) and 11.0–45.8 (pullout), and complete healing rates of 64.7–67.8% versus 21.5–85.7%, respectively. Critically, neither technique reliably corrected meniscal extrusion, and biomechanical superiority was inconsistent across the four comparative studies.
Key Limitation
The comparative clinical dataset is limited to four nonrandomized studies totaling 153 patients with heterogeneous follow-up and healing criteria, making technique-specific efficacy conclusions unreliable.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
To (1) synthesize available clinical data on medial meniscus posterior root tear all-inside repair, (2) compare biomechanical outcomes of all-inside and transtibial pullout repair technique, and (3) compare clinical outcomes of all-inside and transtibial pullout repair technique.
METHODS
A systematic search was performed across PubMed, Embase, Scopus, and Web of Science through August 2025. All studies reporting the clinical outcomes of medial meniscus posterior root tear all-inside repair were included. Furthermore, all studies that compared clinical or biomechanical outcomes of all-inside versus pullout repair were included. A qualitative synthesis of the data including functional scores, meniscus healing, and extrusion along with heterogeneity and risk of bias assessments is provided.
RESULTS
Twelve studies (8 clinical, 4 biomechanical) met inclusion criteria. Four clinical studies (n = 153; mean follow-up, 23.7 months) directly compared the 2 techniques. Both repairs yielded significant postoperative improvements in patient-reported outcome measures. One study reported the proportions of patients achieving minimal clinically important difference to be higher in the all-inside group. The range of postoperative medial meniscal extrusion in the all-inside group was comparable with the pullout group (-2.2 mm to -0.6, vs -1.9 to +0.1). The change in Lysholm score ranged from 20.8 to 38.2 in all-inside and 11.0 to 45.8 in pullout repair. Complete meniscus healing rate ranged from 64.7% to 67.8% in all-inside and from 21.5% to 85.7% in pullout repair. There are only 4 studies that compared the biomechanical characteristics of all-inside versus transtibial pullout repair. All-inside repair showed higher failure loads in 2 studies, but overall results are contradictory; neither technique showed consistent superior biomechanics.
CONCLUSIONS
The all-inside repair, like the conventional pullout method, is a safe and effective method of medial meniscal root repair with reliable effects on joint's biomechanics, patients' function, minimal clinically important difference rates, and meniscus healing. Importantly, neither technique consistently restores meniscal position, because meaningful correction of extrusion remains unachieved. Given the substantial heterogeneity and predominantly nonrandomized nature of the available evidence, surgical decision-making should be individualized based on procedural context, concomitant procedures (e.g., osteotomy or additional tunnel requirements), and surgeon preference rather than presumed differences in efficacy.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE
All-inside and transtibial pullout meniscus root repair both can restore near-native joint biomechanics at time zero, with similar load to failure and both methods fail to correct extrusion. The persistent failure to correct extrusion highlights a fundamental limitation of current repair strategies and supports the need for adjunctive approaches, such as meniscal centralization, to optimize long-term joint preservation.