<- Back to digest

Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics - 2026-10-01 - Journal Article; Comparative Study

Outcomes of Arthroscopic Bony Bankart Repair Compared With Soft-Tissue Only Bankart Repair in the Adolescent Population.

Grewal RS, Berger GK, Pennock AT, Bomar JD, Edmonds EW

retrospective cohortLOE IIIn = 50 (25 BB, 25 NBB)Mean 4.2 years

Topics

pediatricsshoulder elbowsports
PMID: 41686915DOI: 10.1097/BPO.0000000000003234View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

Arthroscopic bony Bankart repair in adolescents yields equivalent failure rates (32% vs. 32%) and return-to-sport rates (88% vs. 80%) compared to soft-tissue-only Bankart repair, despite mean glenoid bone loss of 18.9% in the bony cohort.

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This study compared outcomes of arthroscopic Bankart repair in adolescents with bony Bankart (BB) lesions versus soft-tissue-only (NBB) lesions over a minimum 2-year follow-up. BB fragments averaged 5.7 mm sagittal width representing 18.9% glenoid bone loss, and BB shoulders required more suture anchors (6.0 vs. 4.9). Failure rates (32% both groups), revision rates (12% BB vs. 4% NBB, p=NS), return-to-sport (88% vs. 80%), and PASS and qDASH scores were equivalent, though SANE scores were modestly higher in the BB group (91.2 vs. 85.2, p=0.03).

Key Limitation

Mean glenoid bone loss of 18.9% approaches but does not exceed the 20–25% threshold typically cited for Latarjet, limiting generalizability to higher-grade bone loss cases.

Original Abstract

BACKGROUND

Outcomes of arthroscopic management of bony Bankart (BB) lesions may result in higher reinjury rates, revision surgeries, and return-to-sport outcomes compared with adolescent patients with no bony Bankart (NBB) lesions.

METHODS

Adolescent patients undergoing arthroscopic stabilization (2010 to 2023) with a minimum of 2 years follow-up were categorized into BB and NBB cohorts based on MRI and intraoperative findings. Preinjury glenoid diameter was estimated using a best-fit circle technique. Data collected included demographics, injury details, surgical techniques, and surgical outcomes. Patient-reported outcomes were assessed using single assessment numeric evaluation (SANE), pediatric/adolescent shoulder survey (PASS), and quick Disabilities of the Arm Shoulder and Hand (qDASH) scores.

RESULTS

Fifty patients were analyzed (25 BB, 25 NBB), with mean age 16.9±0.9 years (BB) and 16.6±1.0 years (NBB) ( P =0.32), and overall mean follow-up 4.2 years. BB was associated with males ( P =0.02) and collision mechanisms of injury ( P =0.02). BB utilized more suture anchors (6.0±1.2 vs. 4.9±1.4) ( P =0.005). Preinjury glenoid diameter was larger in the BB (29.9±2.6 vs. 26.2±2.3 mm) ( P <0.001). Mean sagittal width of the BB fragment measured 5.7±1.5 mm (range: 3 to 10 mm) and represented a mean glenoid bone loss of 18.9%±4.5%. Surgery failure rates (32% BB vs. 32% NBB), revision surgery rates (12% BB vs. 4% NBB), and return to sport rates (88% BB vs. 80% NBB) were not significantly different. SANE scores were higher with BB (91.2±9.9 vs. 85.2±12.8) ( P =0.03), yet no differences were found in PASS and qDASH outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

BB was associated with larger glenoid diameters, male sex, and collision injuries, but outcomes did not appear to vary when compared with NBB shoulders, refuting the hypothesis that bony Bankart shoulders would have poorer short-term to mid-term outcomes over time compared with those with only soft-tissue injury. Recurrent instability and revision surgery rates remain high in this youthful population regardless of the presence of a bony Bankart-associated anterior instability.