JOA - 2026-10-01 - Journal Article; Comparative Study
Single- versus Dual-Component Revision Following Total Knee Arthroplasty Failure for Isolated Tibial or Femoral Loosening.
Nwankwo TN, Olson NR, Ray JR, Jaicks CM, Sershon RA
Topics
Key Takeaway
Single- and dual-component revision TKA for isolated aseptic loosening yield equivalent rerevision rates (11.2% vs 9.7%) at mean 4.5-year follow-up.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study asked whether single-component revision produces inferior outcomes compared to dual-component revision in TKAs failing from isolated femoral or tibial aseptic loosening. A retrospective review of 288 first-time revision TKAs across 9 high-volume surgeons compared rerevision rates, complications, ROM, and PROMs between strategies. Rerevision rates were statistically equivalent (11.2% single vs 9.7% dual, P=0.615), 90-day complication rates were similarly low, and PROMs improved equivalently in both cohorts.
Key Limitation
Retrospective design with no standardized criteria for component retention means the decision to perform single- versus dual-component revision was surgeon-dependent, making the two groups inherently non-equivalent at baseline.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Aseptic loosening is a leading cause of failure in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). When loosening is limited to either the femoral or tibial component, the choice between single- and dual-component revision remains a debated topic. This investigation examines outcomes between single- versus dual-component revision for isolated component loosening in TKA.
METHODS
A retrospective review was conducted of 288 first-time revision TKAs performed for isolated femoral or tibial aseptic component loosening between February 2005 and December 2024 by 9 high-volume arthroplasty surgeons. The mean follow-up was 4.5 years (range, zero to 17.0). Patients were stratified by revision strategy: single- or dual-component. The primary outcome was survivorship and rerevision rate. The secondary outcomes included complications, postoperative range of motion (ROM), and patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs). Multivariable Cox regressions evaluated factors associated with rerevision risk.
RESULTS
Survivorship analysis showed comparable revision rates between both groups (P = 0.615). There were no differences found between the overall rerevision rate for single-component revision (11.2%, 16 of 134) and dual-component revision (9.7%, 15 of 154). The 90-day complications were similarly low in both groups (P > 0.05). Cox regressions identified no independent predictors of rerevision, including revision strategy (P > 0.05). Both cohorts demonstrated improvements in ROM and PROMs postoperatively, with no significant difference in PROMs (P > 0.05).
CONCLUSIONS
In patients who had isolated femoral or tibial loosening, single- and dual-component revision TKA offer comparable survivorship and functional outcomes. These findings support the use of surgeon discretion in determining component retention during revision TKA.