JOA - 2026-10-01 - Journal Article; Comparative Study
Is the Posterior Cruciate Ligament Necessary in Cruciate-Substituting Total Knee Arthroplasty? A Cadaveric Comparison of Knee Kinematics With or Without the Posterior Cruciate Ligament Versus the Native Knee.
Shigekiyo S, Hamada D, Wada K, Tamaki Y, Sairyo K
Topics
Key Takeaway
In cruciate-substituting TKA with a medial-dished insert, PCL preservation produced rotational kinematics matching the native knee in early flexion and AP kinematics matching the native knee beyond 80° of flexion, whereas PCL sacrifice did not.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This cadaveric study used a within-specimen repeated-measures design to compare knee kinematics of native knee, medial-dished (MD) TKA with PCL preservation (MD PCLplus), and MD TKA with PCL sacrifice (MD PCLminus) across the full arc of motion using image-free robotic-assisted implantation and navigation-based kinematic recording. Both MD groups showed increased internal rotation at full extension versus native knee. MD PCLplus reproduced native rotational kinematics in early flexion and native AP position beyond midflexion, while MD PCLminus showed significantly greater anterior tibial position beyond 80° of flexion compared to native.
Key Limitation
The sample size of eight cadaveric specimens is insufficient to detect small but clinically meaningful kinematic differences, and the absence of in vivo muscle loading limits direct translation to functional outcomes.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
This study sought to determine knee kinematics after cruciate-substituting total knee arthroplasty (TKA) using an insert with or without the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) in the same-specimen fresh-frozen cadavers using a within-knee repeated-measures design.
METHODS
There were eight specimens that underwent TKA with a medial-dished (MD) type insert, one of the cruciate-substituting designs, using an image-free robotic-assisted surgical system. Knee kinematics were evaluated using an image-free knee navigation system. We recorded the kinematics of the native knee, TKA with MD and PCL preservation (MD PCLplus), and TKA with MD and PCL dissection (MD PCLminus) from full extension to maximum flexion using the navigation system. Differences in the rotational and antero-posterior (A-P) positions between the native knee and TKA in each MD group were examined for statistical significance.
RESULTS
At full extension, knees in both MD groups were initially in a more internally rotated position compared with the native knee. In the initial-flexion phase, the MD PCLplus group exhibited rotational position changes similar to those of the native knee, whereas the MD PCLminus group did not. There was no significant difference in rotational position beyond midflexion between knees in either of the MD groups and the native knee. The A-P position through to the midflexion position was similar between the native knee and knees in both MD groups. Compared with the native knee, there was no significant difference after midflexion in the MD PCLplus group, but the anterior position was significantly greater after 80° in the MD and PCL dissection group.
CONCLUSIONS
In TKA using the MD insert, preservation of the PCL better reproduces the AP and rotational kinematics of the native knee compared with dissection of the PCL.