JOA - 2026-10-09 - Journal Article
Bleeding and Hemostasis Optimization in Primary and Revision Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Structured Expert-Opinion Survey.
Chen AF, Mont MA, Smitterberg CW, Aflatooni JO, Cohen-Rosenblum AR, Della Valle CJ, Duensing IM, Edelstein AI, Grynovicki EN, Ihekweazu UN, Jenkins S, Jones RB, Marino DV, Palmer CW, Sierra RJ, Varacallo MA, Zlotnicki JP
Topics
Key Takeaway
A panel of 14 arthroplasty surgeons reached unanimous agreement that disruptive bleeding in TKA should be defined as a composite of care-altering events (including symptomatic Hgb drop >3 g/dL, persistent drainage, transfusion, reoperation, embolization, and readmission) rather than isolated quantitative blood-loss thresholds.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This survey asked 14 fellowship-trained arthroplasty surgeons to establish consensus definitions and management thresholds for disruptive bleeding in primary and revision TKA across domains including risk stratification, intraoperative patterns, drainage assessment, escalation criteria, and topical hemostatic agent use. Using a priori ≥70% agreement threshold, respondents unanimously endorsed a composite definition of disruptive bleeding and identified thrombocytopenia and anticoagulant use as the top risk factors (14/14), while routine prophylactic topical hemostatics were rejected for primary TKA (only 2/14 supported) but selectively favored in revision cases (7/14). Significant variability persisted around drainage volume thresholds and intervention timing, limiting actionable consensus in those domains.
Key Limitation
The sample of 14 surgeons is far too small to constitute generalizable expert consensus, and selection bias in recruitment is not described, making it impossible to assess representativeness of the opinions captured.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Disruptive bleeding following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) continues to affect postoperative recovery despite advances in perioperative blood management, with wound drainage and dressing-related findings common clinical concerns. Conventional definitions based on estimated blood loss or hemoglobin decline may not capture bleeding events that alter clinical management. This study sought to establish agreement on disruptive bleeding in TKA and identify clinically relevant factors guiding monitoring, escalation, and hemostatic decision-making.
METHODS
A survey-based study was conducted among 14 fellowship-trained arthroplasty surgeons who had experience in primary and revision TKA. Domains included risk factors, definitions of disruptive bleeding, intraoperative bleeding patterns, postoperative drainage assessment, escalation criteria, and the use of topical hemostatic agents. Responses included Likert-scale ratings, categorical selections, and free-text data. High agreement for items was defined a priori as ≥ 70% agreement.
RESULTS
Respondents supported defining disruptive bleeding as a composite of clinically meaningful outcomes rather than isolated quantitative measures. There was unanimous agreement to include operational indicators (symptomatic hemoglobin decline greater than three g/dL and persistent wound drainage) and downstream events (transfusion, reoperation, embolization, and readmission). Thrombocytopenia and anticoagulant use were important risk factors (n = 14 of 14), followed by coagulopathy and liver disease (n = 12 of 14). Escalation triggers included suspected arterial bleeding (n = 14 of 14), expanding hematoma (n = 13 of 14), hemodynamic instability (n = 13 of 14), neurovascular compromise (n = 13 of 14), and drainage beyond postoperative day five (n = 12 of 14). Routine prophylactic use of topical hemostatic agents was not supported in primary TKA (n = 2 of 14), but was selectively favored in revision cases (n = 7 of 14). Variability remained regarding drainage thresholds and timing of intervention.
CONCLUSIONS
Disruptive bleeding in TKA was viewed as a composite construct defined by events that alter care rather than isolated numeric blood-loss measures. These findings represent an exploratory, hypothesis-generating framework requiring multidisciplinary and data-driven validation.