JOT - 2026-10-12 - Journal Article
Comparison of novel anterior fixation method, W-plate, versus superior parasymphyseal plating in anterior posterior compression type III pelvic ring injuries: a biomechanical study.
Krieg BA, Baldini T, Orear C, Onodera KM, Tucker NJ, Schlauch A, Hellwinkel JE, Schaffer NE, Mauffrey C
Topics
Key Takeaway
In a composite pelvis APC-III model, W-plate anterior fixation reduced inferior pubic symphysis displacement by 0.7 mm versus superior parasymphyseal plating under single-leg stance (0.5 vs 1.2 mm, Cohen's d = 1.47), with equivalent stiffness and load-to-failure (~1411 vs 1545 N).
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study compared W-plate versus superior parasymphyseal plating (SPSP) for anterior ring fixation in APC-III injuries using composite pelves with posterior iliosacral screw fixation, tested under single-leg stance axial load and external rotation via Instron machine. W-plating showed a large effect size favoring reduced inferior pubic symphysis displacement (0.5 vs 1.2 mm, Cohen's d = 1.47) but no statistically significant differences in construct stiffness (98.9 vs 105 N/mm, p=0.6), external rotation stiffness (p=0.3), or load-to-failure (1411 vs 1545 N, p=0.4). Both constructs failed at the posterior fixation site.
Key Limitation
The composite bone model eliminates patient-specific bone quality, ligamentous contributions, and muscle forces, making direct extrapolation to clinical fixation strength unreliable.
Original Abstract
OBJECTIVES
To compare stiffness, displacement, and load to failure (LTF) patterns of a novel anterior pelvic plating technique, W-plating, to superior parasymphyseal plating (SPSP) in anterior posterior compression type III (APC III) pelvic ring injuries in a biomechanical model.
METHODS
Twelve fourth generation composite pelves with induced APC III injuries stabilized with posterior screw fixation and either W-plating or SPSP were stressed via the Instron machine under single leg stance (SLS) axial load and external rotation (ER) load. Motion was analyzed at the pubic symphysis (PS) and sacroiliac joints (SIJ). PS and SIJ displacement, rotation, and stiffness were compared between the W-plate and SPSP groups under simulated stressed conditions. T-test was used to compare means and significance was set at p<0.05. Unadjusted p-values were reported alongside effect sizes (Cohen's d) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) to provide additional context regarding the magnitude and potential biomechanical relevance of the observed differences.
RESULTS
The W-plate demonstrated less inferior PS displacement than the SPSP under SLS with a large observed effect size (0.5 ± 0.4 mm vs 1.2 ± 0.5 mm, respectively, Cohen's d = 1.47). Average PS displacement also demonstrated a large effect size favoring the W-plate construct (Cohen's d = 1.07), though statistical significance was not reached (0.3 ± 0.3 mm vs 0.7 ± 0.3 mm respectively, p = 0.07). There were no significant differences in stiffness in the SLS for the W-plate versus SPSP (98.9 ± 11.2 vs 105 ± 6.6 N/mm, respectively, p = 0.6) or in ER (4.4 ± 2.2 v 3.1 ± 1.6, respectively, p = 0.3). When loaded to failure, the W-plate and the SPSP both failed at the posterior fixation with no significant difference between groups (1411± 221 v 1545 ± 225 N, respectively p = 0.4).
CONCLUSIONS
In a biomechanical analysis of induced APC-III pelvic ring injury, W-plating performed similarly to SPSP in stiffness, displacement, and LTF. W-plating for anterior pelvic ring fixation was found to be biomechanically similar to SPSP with potentially increased resistance to anterior ring displacement.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
V.