<- Back to digest

Injury - 2026-10-07 - Journal Article

Force measurement in circular external fixation frames reflects construct stability: A laboratory proof-of-concept study.

Naeem H, Maroy R, Stewart T, Harwood P, Howard A

biomechanicalLOE Vn = 3 four-ring Ilizarov frame constructs (Perspex bone analogue models)N/A

Topics

traumabasic science
PMID: 42854536DOI: 10.1016/j.injury.2026.113768View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

Integrated load cell force measurement within Ilizarov frames discriminates grossly unstable from intact constructs with AUC ≥ 0.91, but discrimination drops to AUC 0.699–0.838 near union, limiting utility at the clinically critical decision point for frame removal.

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This proof-of-concept study tested whether load cell force measurement within circular external fixation frames correlates with construct stiffness across simulated healing stages using Perspex analogues loaded to 700 N. Force decreased progressively with increasing construct stiffness (Kruskal-Wallis p < 0.0001), and ROC analysis demonstrated strong separation between grossly unstable and intact conditions (AUC ≥ 0.91). However, discrimination was substantially reduced between higher-stability models and intact bone (AUC 0.699–0.838), and absolute force values varied with sensor position, though rank order was preserved across configurations.

Key Limitation

The Perspex bone analogue eliminates biological variability—callus stiffness progression, cortical remodeling, and soft tissue contributions—making the AUC values optimistic relative to what would be observed in vivo.

Original Abstract

BACKGROUND

Circular external fixation frames are widely used in limb reconstruction, however determining the optimal time for frame removal remains challenging. Current approaches rely on clinical and radiological assessment, both of which have recognised limitations. Mechanical assessment of construct stability offers a potential alternative, but existing approaches have not translated widely into clinical practice, in part due to reliance on absolute measurement thresholds.

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether force measurement within a circular external fixation frame varies systematically with fracture site stability, and to assess whether this measurement may support monitoring of healing progression.

METHODS

Three similar four-ring Ilizarov frame constructs were assembled using a Perspex bone analogue. A load cell was integrated into the frame and used to measure force during axial loading to 700 N. Models representing different stages of fracture healing were simulated using varying fracture gaps and materials of differing stiffness. Measurements were obtained across multiple sensor positions and configurations. Force measurements were compared between models using non-parametric statistical methods. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis was performed to assess separation between conditions.

RESULTS

Force measured within the frame decreased progressively with increasing construct stiffness. A significant relationship between model stability and measured force was observed (Kruskal-Wallis p < 0.0001). Clear separation was demonstrated between grossly unstable and intact constructs; however, overlap between higher stability models and intact bone was evident. ROC analysis showed strong discrimination when considering all unstable conditions (AUC ≥ 0.91), but performance was reduced when restricted to higher stability models (AUC 0.699-0.838). Absolute force measurements varied with sensor configuration, although the rank order of conditions was preserved.

CONCLUSION

Force measurement within a circular external fixation frame reflects construct stability in an in vitro model. Whilst absolute values are dependent on construct configuration and show reduced discrimination near union, consistent directional changes suggest that serial within-subject measurement may provide a useful approach to monitoring healing progression. These findings support further evaluation of longitudinal measurement strategies in clinical studies.