Arthroscopy - 2026-10-13 - Journal Article
Congruent-Arc Posterior Distal Tibial Allograft Shows Greater Radiographic Glenoid Concavity Compared With Traditional Lateral Tibial Allograft in Glenoid Bone Loss.
Tummala SV, Lai CH, Tarabichi S, Hoffer A, Flug JA, Tokish JM
Topics
Key Takeaway
Congruent-arc posterior distal tibial allograft produces positive glenoid concavity (+2.9 mm, +22.9°) while traditional lateral distal tibial allograft produces negative concavity (−2.3 mm, −9.78°) on CT measurement.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study compared glenoid concavity depth and slope angle between congruent-arc (CA-DTA, posterior tibial surface) and traditional (lateral tibial surface) distal tibial allografts using CT measurements from 32 patients ≤35 years old. Two independent reviewers measured coronal and sagittal reconstructions; CA-DTA produced significantly greater concavity depth (2.9 vs −2.3 mm, P<.001) and slope angle (22.9° vs −9.78°, P<.001). All CA-DTAs yielded positive values while all traditional DTAs yielded negative values, indicating the CA-DTA consistently recreates a concave glenoid contour.
Key Limitation
Radiographic morphology on unmodified CT scans does not replicate the final graft geometry after intraoperative contouring, fixation, and biological incorporation at the glenoid.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
To compare radiographically the concavity depth and slope angle of the congruent-arc distal tibial allograft (CA-DTA), harvested from the posterior distal tibia, with the traditional lateral distal tibial allograft (traditional DTA) used for glenoid reconstruction in anterior shoulder instability with bone loss.
METHODS
A convenience sample of 32 ankle computed tomography scans from patients ≤35 years old without prior trauma, arthritis, or ankle pathology were retrospectively reviewed. Using standardized coronal (traditional DTA) and sagittal (CA-DTA) reconstructions, 2 independent reviewers measured allograft concavity depth (mm) and slope angle. Paired t tests compared traditional versus CA-DTA measurements. Intraclass correlation coefficients assessed reliability. Significance was set at P < .05.
RESULTS
The mean age of patients was 25.2 years, with 50% (n = 18) of patients being male. Compared with the traditional DTA, the CA-DTA showed significantly greater glenoid concavity change (2.9 ± 0.65 mm vs -2.3 ± 0.71 mm; P < .001) and slope angle (22.9°± 4.02 vs -9.78°± 4.07; P < .001). All CA-DTAs showed positive concavity and slope, whereas all traditional DTAs produced negative values.
CONCLUSIONS
The CA-DTA consistently increased both concavity and slope, whereas the traditional DTA decreased these measures. By leveraging the posterior tibial surface, the CA-DTA more reliably recreates the anatomic "half-pipe" glenoid contour that contributes to bony concavity-compression-based stability.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE
The CA-DTA offers a graft alternative that more reliably restores glenoid concavity in anterior shoulder instability with glenoid bone loss. This has potential implications for improved glenohumeral stability and clinical outcomes.