KSSTA - 2026-10-15 - Journal Article
Low graft failure after primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in professional soccer players: A retrospective cohort study of 232 knees from the SANTI Study Group.
Santamaria F, Santos PM, Ayata M, Wehbe H, Sonnery-Cottet V, Campos JP, Corti J, Vieira TD, Sonnery-Cottet B
Topics
Key Takeaway
Primary ACLR in professional soccer players achieved a 5.6% graft failure rate at mean 100 months, with LEAP showing a numerically lower failure rate (4.5% vs. 12.9%) that did not reach statistical significance (HR 2.48, p=0.246).
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study evaluated graft failure rates and associated risk factors after primary ACLR in professional soccer players, comparing isolated ACLR (n=31) to ACLR+LEAP (n=201). Graft failure occurred in 13 knees (5.6%), with no statistically significant survival difference between groups despite a numerically lower failure rate with LEAP. Preoperative laxity ≥7 mm (HR 2.72, p=0.014) and BPTB graft use (HR 3.14, p=0.037) were independent predictors of reoperation, and contralateral ACL injury occurred in 27.1% of knees.
Key Limitation
The 6.5:1 LEAP-to-isolated ACLR ratio reflects surgeon selection bias rather than randomization, making any conclusion about LEAP efficacy statistically unreliable given the wide confidence interval (HR 0.49–9.87).
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
This study aimed to determine graft failure rates after primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) in professional soccer players and to evaluate factors associated with graft failure, including lateral extra-articular augmentation.
METHODS
A retrospective cohort study included 232 primary ACLRs in 215 professional soccer players: isolated ACLR (n = 31) and ACLR combined with a lateral extra-articular procedure (LEAP) (n = 201). The primary endpoint was graft failure, defined as symptomatic rupture confirmed clinically and by imaging or revision surgery. Time-to-event analyses accounted for variable follow-up. Contralateral ACL injury was recorded descriptively.
RESULTS
At a mean follow-up of 100 months, 13 graft failures occurred (5.6%). Unadjusted failure rates were lower in ACLR + LEAP versus isolated ACLR (4.5% vs. 12.9%), but survival analysis showed no significant difference (hazard ratio [HR] 2.48; 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.49-9.87; p = 0.246). Multivariable Cox regression identified no independent predictors of graft failure. Mean time to graft failure was longer in the ACLR + LEAP group than in the isolated ACLR group (54.8 ± 52.0 vs. 36.6 ± 38.2 months). Reoperations occurred in 32 knees (17.7%), with rates of 15.2% in the ACLR + LEAP group and 30.0% in the isolated ACLR group (p = 0.0528). Increased preoperative laxity (≥7 mm; HR 2.72; 95% CI 1.23-6.17; p = 0.014) and bone-patellar tendon-bone graft use (HR 3.14; 95% CI 1.26-7.20; p = 0.037) were independent risk factors for reoperation. Contralateral ACL injury occurred in 27.1% of knees, more frequently in female athletes (48.7% vs. 22.8%). Among patients who experienced graft failure, 53.8% also had a contralateral ACL injury.
CONCLUSION
Primary ACL reconstruction in professional soccer players was associated with durable long-term graft survival. Although ACLR combined with an LEAP was associated with fewer graft failures than isolated ACLR, an independent protective effect was not confirmed. The high rate of contralateral ACL injury highlights the multifactorial nature of reinjury risk in this elite population.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Level III, retrospective cohort study.