Spine - 2026-10-14 - Journal Article
Surgical and Radiographic Outcomes in Cervical Deformity Patients with High T1 Slope and High C2 Slope (HTHC) Versus Low T1 Slope and High C2 Slope (LTHC): Distinct Phenotypes of Cervical-Only versus Global Spinal Deformity.
Kucherina A, Norris Z, Balouch E, Lafage R, Soroceanu A, Gum J, Smith JS, Eastlack R, Mundis G, Gupta M, Hostin R, Klineberg E, Lenke L, Ames C, Shaffrey C, Passias P, Lee S, Hamilton DK, Lafage V, Schwab F, Lau D, Bess S, Protopsaltis TS, International Spine Study Group (ISSG)
Topics
Key Takeaway
Among cervical deformity patients with C2 slope >30°, those with additional T1 slope >30° (HTHC) achieved MCID on NDI at less than half the rate of LTHC patients (45.9% vs. 71.0%) despite undergoing significantly more extensive surgery.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study stratified operative cervical deformity patients with preoperative C2 slope >30° by T1 slope (≤30° LTHC vs. >30° HTHC) to determine whether combined T1S/C2S identifies distinct deformity phenotypes with differing surgical demands and outcomes. HTHC patients required more posterior levels fused (10.3 vs. 6.7), more circumferential fusions (66.7% vs. 38.7%), and more caudal lowest instrumented vertebra (T7 vs. T3). Despite greater absolute radiographic correction, HTHC patients had smaller 2-year NDI improvement (-6.2 vs. -14.6 points; P=0.013), fewer achieving MCID (45.9% vs. 71.0%; P=0.022), and HTHC phenotype independently predicted worse functional recovery (β=+7.4; P=0.020).
Key Limitation
Retrospective group allocation with unequal cohort sizes and no standardized surgical protocol across centers introduces selection bias in operative decision-making that confounds the relationship between phenotype and outcomes.
Original Abstract
STUDY DESIGN
Retrospective analysis of a prospective multicenter operative cervical deformity (CD) database.
OBJECTIVE
To determine whether T1 slope (T1S) and C2 slope (C2S) together identify distinct CD phenotypes: cervical-only versus global sagittal deformity, and to compare surgical invasiveness, radiographic correction, and patient-reported outcomes.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA
T1S and C2S mark cervical malalignment, and elevated T1S has been linked to global sagittal malalignment. Combining them may distinguish CD-only from global deformity on cervical imaging alone.
METHODS
Operative CD patients with ≥2 years follow-up and preoperative C2S >30° were stratified by T1S into low T1S-high C2S (LTHC; ≤30°) and high T1S-high C2S (HTHC; >30°). Multivariable regression assessed group effect on 2-year NDI change, adjusted for age, sex, baseline NDI, and posterior levels fused. NDI MCID was set a priori at ≥7 points per the ISSG threshold.
RESULTS
Ninety-two patients met criteria (31 LTHC, 61 HTHC). HTHC patients were older (64.7 vs. 60.0 years; P=0.035) with higher Charlson index (P=0.022). Preoperatively, HTHC had greater thoracic kyphosis, TPA, cSVA, PI-LL mismatch, and C7 SVA (all P≤0.010). HTHC underwent more extensive surgery: more posterior levels fused (10.3 vs. 6.7), more circumferential fusions (66.7% vs. 38.7%), and more caudal LIV (T7 vs. T3) (all P<0.05). At 2 years, HTHC retained higher TK and cSVA despite greater absolute correction. Baseline NDI was similar (P=0.906), but 2-year NDI improvement was smaller in HTHC (-6.2 vs. -14.6 points; P=0.013), and fewer achieved MCID (45.9% vs. 71.0%; P=0.022). HTHC remained an independent predictor of smaller improvement (β=+7.4; P=0.020). Reoperation, DJK, and complication rates did not differ.
CONCLUSIONS
Among CD patients with elevated C2S, additional elevated T1S identifies a global-deformity phenotype requiring more invasive correction and showing smaller 2-year patient-reported improvement despite comparable complications. T1S and C2S, measurable on cervical imaging alone, screen for which CD patients warrant full-spine imaging.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
III (retrospective analysis of prospectively collected multicenter data).