AJSM - 2026-10-12 - Journal Article
High-Grade Percutaneous Medial Collateral Ligament Pie-Crusting Is Not Associated With Clinically Meaningful Valgus Instability.
Nishioka T, Thamrongskulsiri N, Casanova F, Ackermann J, Morgan JT, Moews LD, Vega TF, Spaan J, Chahla J
Topics
Key Takeaway
High-grade percutaneous MCL pie-crusting during MMPRT repair produces a mean side-to-side medial compartment gapping difference of only 1.21 mm, well below the 3.2-mm clinically meaningful instability threshold.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This retrospective case series asked whether high-grade percutaneous MCL pie-crusting—defined by audible/palpable release and ≥6 mm intraoperative compartment opening—causes clinically meaningful valgus instability after MMPRT repair. Bilateral valgus stress radiographs at 20° flexion were obtained at mean 5.9 months; operative knees showed 7.84 mm gapping versus 6.62 mm contralateral, yielding a mean side-to-side difference of 1.21 mm (95% CI, 0.73–1.70 mm). This difference was significantly below the pre-specified 3.2-mm instability threshold (P<.001).
Key Limitation
The sample size of 21 patients, absence of preoperative stress radiographs, and short mean follow-up of 5.9 months preclude conclusions about whether residual laxity is permanent or whether it affects functional outcomes.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Medial collateral ligament (MCL) pie-crusting is used during medial meniscal surgery to improve visualization and reduce the risk of chondral injuries. However, some surgeons extend the release site beyond routine incremental perforation, and the effect of this more extensive release on postoperative medial laxity remains unclear.
PURPOSE
To determine whether high-grade percutaneous MCL pie-crusting during medial meniscus posterior root tear (MMPRT) repair results in clinically meaningful valgus instability postoperatively as assessed by valgus stress radiography.
STUDY DESIGN
Case series; Level of evidence, 4.
METHODS
A retrospective review was performed of patients who underwent isolated MMPRT repair with high-grade MCL pie-crusting and no prior knee ligament surgery. High-grade pie-crusting was defined intraoperatively by an audible and palpable release and a substantial medial compartment opening (≥6 mm) under arthroscopic visualization. Postoperative bilateral valgus stress radiographs were obtained at a mean of 5.9 ± 2.0 months with the knee positioned at 20° of flexion. Gapping was measured in millimeters, and the side-to-side difference was calculated using the contralateral knee as an internal control. An a priori power analysis based on a 3.2-mm threshold for clinically meaningful medial-sided laxity demonstrated a required sample size of 15 patients. The side-to-side difference in medial compartment gapping was analyzed using the 1-sample t test compared with the 3.2-mm threshold.
RESULTS
A total of 21 patients met inclusion criteria. The mean medial compartment gapping was 7.84 ± 1.65 mm in the operative knee and 6.62 ± 1.37 mm in the contralateral knee. The mean side-to-side difference was 1.21 ± 1.07 mm (95% CI, 0.73-1.70 mm). The observed difference was significantly less than the 3.2-mm threshold associated with clinically meaningful medial-sided instability ( P < .001).
CONCLUSION
High-grade percutaneous MCL pie-crusting advanced to a defined intraoperative endpoint during MMPRT repair resulted in small increases in medial compartment gapping that remained below biomechanically defined instability thresholds. These preliminary findings suggest that high-grade MCL pie-crusting improves visualization and instrumentation without being associated with clinically meaningful valgus laxity postoperatively.