JHS - 2026-10-12 - Journal Article
Outcomes of the Surgical Management of Clinodactyly: A Systematic Review.
Devetzis K, Beni R, McGhee J, Hei To EY, Lam WL, Horwitz MD
Topics
Key Takeaway
Surgical management of clinodactyly (physiolysis 76%, osteotomy 24%) reduces mean digital angulation from 41° to 21°, with a 7.3% complication rate and 9% reoperation rate, but no included study used validated patient-reported outcome measures.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This PRISMA 2020-compliant systematic review evaluated surgical outcomes for congenital clinodactyly across 8 studies identified from 818 screened, comparing physiolysis and osteotomy. Mean angular correction was 20° (41° to 21°), with reoperations occurring more frequently after physiolysis than osteotomy. No standardized indications, uniform success definitions, or validated PROMs existed across any included study, despite generally high parental satisfaction.
Key Limitation
With only 119 patients across 8 studies and no validated PROMs, the evidence base is insufficient to establish superiority of either technique or to define meaningful patient-centered success thresholds.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
This systematic review evaluated outcomes of surgical management for congenital clinodactyly, focusing on physiolysis and osteotomy.
METHODS
A systematic review was conducted in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses 2020 guidelines, registered on the International Prospective register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO). MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched for studies reporting operative management of congenital clinodactyly published up to December 2025. Data extraction and bias assessment (Newcastle-Ottawa Scale) were performed independently by two reviewers. Outcomes were analyzed descriptively.
RESULTS
Of 818 studies screened, 8 were included, comprising 119 patients (165 digits). Physiolysis was performed in 76% of cases and osteotomy in 24%. The mean age of the physiolysis group was 6.1 years (0.6-12.3) and 7.2 years (0.6-16.4) for the osteotomy group. Mean preoperative angulation was 41°, improving to 21° after surgery. All techniques demonstrated angular improvement; however, no clear criteria exist for guiding the choice of procedure alongside disparity in the threshold for surgical intervention, with some studies quoting >20° to 25° as an indication. The overall complication rate was 7.3%, and reoperation was required in 9% of cases; reoperations were most frequently following physiolysis. Outcome reporting was inconsistent, with variable definitions of success and limited distinction between clinical and radiological measures. There were no studies using validated patient-reported outcome measures; limited qualitative feedback suggested generally high levels of patient or parental satisfaction despite residual deformity.
CONCLUSIONS
Both techniques achieve reduction in angulation; however, standardized indications and robust outcome measures are needed to guide practice. Outcome reporting was heterogeneous, and most notably, there is a complete absence of validated patient-reported outcome measures across all included studies, despite generally high reported satisfaction, representing a major gap in patient-centered outcome assessment.
TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Therapeutic IIIa.