JOT - 2026-10-22 - Journal Article
Outcomes Following Operative Management of Distal Humerus Nonunions.
Harrison NJ, Yu Z, Bloomer A, Chen AT, Mir H, Babcock S, Miller AN, Farooq H, Obremskey W, Adams D, Afetse EK, Arthur R, Averkamp BJ, Bailey G, Bess LE, Braswell MJ, Bulloch L, Burger J, Carroll E, Churchil C, Cohen-Tanugi S, Cuadra M, Danelson KA, Girardi C, Gutbrod J, Haag LA, Halvorson J, Haynes WB, Hickson K, Holden MB, Hong Z, Hsu JR, Hysong AA, Jolissaint J, Jones J, Karunakar MA, Kempton LB, Koutlas NT, Lance T, Lauck BJ, Leighty K, LeMone AA, Lewis S, Lopas LA, Macknet D, Mastracci J, McKinney AS, McNamara KP, Moreno-Diaz AF, Morrison D, Natoli RM, Odum S, Padovano A, Pallitto P, Paterno AV, Pereira DE, Phelps K, Pierrie S, Pilson H, Posey SL, Ponce B, Randall ZD, Rice O, Rodriguez E, Ruth JM, Sajid MI, Serbin RP, Seymour RB, Sharma I, Sims S, Smith A, Suh YM, Sweeney J, Tatman LM, Titter J, Waddell WH, Wally MK, Wohler A, Wrenn S, and the Evidence-Based Musculoskeletal Injury and Trauma Collaborative (EMIT)
Topics
Key Takeaway
Operative repair of distal humerus nonunions failed in 23.3% of cases, with all 7 failures occurring in patients who had an initial open fracture.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This multicenter retrospective case series evaluated union rates and complications after operative distal humerus nonunion repair across 7 Level I trauma centers. Of 30 patients meeting inclusion criteria, 7 (23.3%) developed recalcitrant nonunion after index nonunion surgery, and 13 (43.3%) experienced at least one postoperative complication. All 7 failures occurred in patients whose index injury was an open fracture, though bivariate analysis could not confirm statistical significance for this association given the sample size.
Key Limitation
The small sample size (n=30 from an initial 54 identified) precluded multivariate analysis, leaving the open fracture–recalcitrant nonunion association based solely on bivariate data and vulnerable to confounding.
Original Abstract
OBJECTIVES
To describe outcomes after distal humerus nonunion surgery and to identify risk factors for failure in the same population.
METHODS
Design: Retrospective case series.
SETTING
Seven, academic, level I trauma centers.
PATIENT SELECTION CRITERIA
Included were patients who underwent operative repair of a distal humerus (OTA/AO 13) nonunion and were ≥18 years old. Patients were excluded if they had clinical or serologic signs of infection prior to nonunion repair, or if their follow-up was less than 180 days and their surgery could not otherwise be classified as a success or failure.
OUTCOME MEASURES AND COMPARISONS
This study measured the rate of recalcitrant nonunion and complications following distal humerus nonunion surgery. It additionally evaluated associations between union rate and demographics, injury characteristics, and nonunion surgery characteristics.
RESULTS
Fifty-four patients with distal humerus nonunion were identified. Of the 30 included patients (mean age 47.5 (range 22-71), 18 (60%) male), 7 (23.3%) failed to unite after their index nonunion surgery at a study institution. Thirteen patients (43.3%) experienced one or more postoperative complications. While twenty-one of the 30 (70%) included patients initially sustained an open distal humerus fracture, all 7 patients (100%) who developed a recalcitrant nonunion initially sustained an open fracture. The use of bone graft or bone graft substitute relative to no graft, patient age, body mass index, smoking status, diabetes, and initial OTA/AO fracture classification were not associated with nonunion repair success rate (all p>0.05).
CONCLUSION
This multicenter series challenged the concept that union rates are high, defined by the authors as >90%, following distal humerus nonunion surgery. Though limited by a small sample size that precluded multivariate regression, this study's bivariate analysis suggests that an initially open distal humerus fracture may increase the risk of recalcitrant distal humerus nonunion. Modifiable risk factors were not associated with the success rate of nonunion surgery. These findings can be used to better inform patients' expectations of results and complications following distal humerus nonunion surgery.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Therapeutic level III.