Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics - 2026-10-19 - Journal Article
Principles or Resources? Best Management of Pediatric Femoral Neck Fractures.
Kim CL, Sarkar S, Vergara ADN, Arkader A
Topics
Key Takeaway
Despite a 3-day difference in time-to-surgery (4.42 vs. 7.56 days) and divergent fixation strategies (ORIF vs. percutaneous pinning), AVN and overall complication rates were equivalent between a US Level-1 center and a Latin American trauma hospital across 74 pediatric femoral neck fractures.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This retrospective comparative study asked whether institutional resources or adherence to treatment principles drives outcomes in pediatric femoral neck fractures by comparing a US tertiary pediatric trauma center to a Latin American equivalent over 10 years. Group 1 was older (12.5 vs. 9.35 years), had fewer Delbet Type IV fractures (8% vs. 37%), reached the OR faster (4.42 vs. 7.56 days), and preferentially used ORIF over percutaneous pinning. Despite these differences, no statistically significant difference in AVN or overall complication rates was detected between groups.
Key Limitation
The minimum 3-month follow-up is inadequate to detect AVN, the study's primary outcome of interest, making the conclusion of equivalent complication rates premature and potentially misleading.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Pediatric femoral neck fractures (PFNF) are rare but have a reported complication rate of >30%. To date, there remains a lack of consensus on the definitive risk factors for AVN following PFNF. By comparing the outcomes of PFNF treated at a major US metropolitan area tertiary-level 1 pediatric trauma center (group 1) to an equivalent trauma hospital in a major Latin American capital (group 2), we sought to weigh whether treatment principles or resources are more important for a favorable result.
METHODS
This was a retrospective review of all children (<18 years old) treated for PFNF in the past 10 years at each location. Demographics, treatment, and outcome variables were collected. Fractures were classified by Delbet criteria. Patients with incomplete fractures, pathologic fractures, and those with short follow-up (<3 months) were excluded. Univariate and bivariate statistics were applied.
RESULTS
In all, 74 fractures (73 children) were included, 39 from group 1 and 35 from group 2 (52% male, mean age 11.0±4.11). Patients from group 1 (12.5±3.95 years old) were significantly older compared with group 2 (9.35±3.72 years old, P<0.001). Group 2 had a significantly higher proportion of type 4 Delbet fractures (37% vs. 8%, P=0.01) while no other differences in fracture characteristics were observed between groups. Of the patients who underwent operative treatment for their fractures, the time to surgery was significantly shorter in group 1 (4.42 days) compared with group 2 (7.56 days, P<0.001). The preferred method of surgery was open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) at group 1 and closed reduction and percutaneous pinning at group 2 (P=0.05). There were no differences in overall complication rates, including AVN (P>0.05).
CONCLUSION
While these 2 institutions differ in resources, such as the ability to perform surgery urgently or hardware availability, and despite differences in fracture type, there were no significant differences in the outcome and incidence of complications, including AVN.
LEVELS OF EVIDENCE
Level 3, Retrospective comparative study.