Spine Journal - 2026-10-21 - Journal Article
Longitudinal Discordance Between Functional Recovery and Patient Satisfaction After Lumbar Spine Surgery: A 2-Year Registry Study.
Li X, Teo AQA, Tan JHJ, Chern CWJ, Wang W, Luo N, Hey HWD, Cheng LJ
Topics
Key Takeaway
At 2 years post-lumbar surgery, ODI MID-satisfaction discordance persisted in 24.2% of patients, with EQ VAS discordance reaching 57.0%, confirming that functional recovery and patient satisfaction are non-interchangeable constructs.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This registry-based longitudinal cohort examined 2-year trajectories of ODI, EQ-5D-5L, and satisfaction in 748 adults undergoing primary elective lumbar surgery for degenerative disease. ODI improved through 1 year then plateaued; EQ-5D plateaued earlier at 3–6 months; satisfaction remained stable at approximately 84% throughout. MID-satisfaction discordance decreased from 33.8% to 24.2% for ODI but remained 57.0% for EQ VAS at 2 years, with higher baseline disability predicting MID achievement but paradoxically reducing PASS achievement.
Key Limitation
Single-center registry from a tertiary referral center in Singapore introduces selection bias and limits generalizability across diverse healthcare systems and payer environments.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND CONTEXT
Patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) and satisfaction are used after lumbar spine surgery but capture distinct constructs.
PURPOSE
To characterise 2-year trajectories of disability, health status, improvement, PROM-satisfaction concordance, and associated factors.
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING
Registry-based longitudinal cohort study at a tertiary referral centre in Singapore.
PATIENT SAMPLE
748 adults undergoing primary elective lumbar surgery for degenerative disease with at least 1 postoperative satisfaction assessment.
OUTCOME MEASURES
Oswestry Disability Index (ODI; primary), EQ-5D-5L crosswalk index, EQ VAS, satisfaction, minimum important difference (MID), and ODI patient acceptable symptom state (PASS).
METHODS
PROMs were assessed at baseline and follow-up; satisfaction at 3-6 months, 1 year, and 2 years. Linear mixed-effects models assessed PROM trajectories; logistic mixed-effects models assessed MID and PASS achievement; ordered logistic mixed-effects models assessed satisfaction; and multinomial regression assessed ODI MID-satisfaction concordance. No study-specific funding or conflicts of interest were reported.
RESULTS
ODI improved through 1 year then remained stable, whereas EQ-5D plateaued after 3-6 months. Satisfaction remained approximately 84%. ODI MID-satisfaction discordance decreased from 33.8% to 24.2%; at 2 years, discordance was 28.7% for EQ-5D and 57.0% for EQ VAS. Higher baseline ODI increased the odds of MID achievement but decreased the odds of PASS achievement. Sensitivity analyses supported these trajectories despite attrition. Greater ODI and EQ-5D improvements were associated with greater satisfaction; satisfaction without MID achievement was more common among patients with lower baseline disability.
CONCLUSIONS
Disability, health status, and satisfaction followed different trajectories. Change-based thresholds, acceptable states, and satisfaction are complementary, not interchangeable, outcomes.