BJJ - 2026-11-01 - Journal Article
Barriers to recruitment in paediatric orthopaedic surgical trials : a qualitative study embedded in the Big BOSS trial.
Kirton JA, Achten J, Young B, Perry DC, Cherry MG
Topics
Key Takeaway
The Big BOSS trial comparing surgical approaches for severe stable SCFE was discontinued after recruitment fell significantly short of targets, with 24 surgeons across 21 NHS sites identifying five barrier themes including limited eligible patient availability, equipoise failure, and systemic infrastructure deficits.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This embedded qualitative study used semi-structured interviews with 24 NHS consultant surgeons to identify why the Big BOSS RCT—comparing surgical approaches for severe stable SCFE—failed to recruit adequately and was discontinued. Five barrier themes emerged: limited eligible patient pool (SCFE cases too mild, unstable, or managed outside trial centers), eligibility criteria ambiguity, loss of clinical equipoise driven by personal preference, systemic infrastructure deficits, and patient-level aversion to randomization. Findings indicate that rare, preference-sensitive surgical conditions face compounding structural and attitudinal barriers that standard feasibility estimates fail to capture.
Key Limitation
Findings are limited to NHS consultant surgeons and may not generalize to international healthcare systems with different research infrastructure, reimbursement models, or SCFE case volumes.
Original Abstract
AIMS
Recruitment to randomized controlled trials (RCTs) remains a widely recognized challenge, particularly in surgical and paediatric contexts. The British Orthopaedic Surgery Surveillance (Big BOSS) trial aimed to compare surgical approaches for treating severe stable slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), a relatively rare but serious adolescent hip condition. Despite national estimates suggesting feasibility, recruitment fell significantly short of targets, and Big BOSS was discontinued. This embedded qualitative study explored the perspectives of consultant surgeons to understand the barriers that contributed to the low recruitment for the trial.
METHODS
Semistructured interviews were carried out with 24 consultant surgeons from 21 NHS sites, including recruiting, non-recruiting, and setup sites. Participants were purposely sampled to ensure variation in experience and involvement in trials. Data were analyzed inductively and thematically, guided by constant comparative methods.
RESULTS
Five overarching themes were identified: 1) limited availability of eligible patients, with many cases of SCFE either unstable, too mild or managed outside trial centres; 2) challenges in interpreting and standardizing the eligibility criteria; 3) difficulty maintaining clinical equipoise, as surgeons often relied on personal experience and preferred treatment pathways; 4) systemic and logistical barriers, including limited research infrastructure, scheduling complexity, and demands on the resources for trials; and 5) patient-level factors, such as aversion to invasive procedures, logistical constraints, and predetermined expectations of treatment. Together, these themes revealed how clinical, practical, and ethical tensions limited participation in the trial.
CONCLUSION
This nested qualitative study highlighted the multifaceted barriers to recruitment in complex surgical RCTs, and showed how embedded qualitative research can help to uncover these challenges and guide the management decisions for trials. The findings emphasize the value of a qualitative investigation to understand the underlying processes and challenges within a trial. This approach facilitates the development of adaptive recruitment strategies, and supports more realistic planning when designing RCTs involving rare conditions or preference-sensitive treatments.