JOA - 2026-11-01 - Journal Article
Varus/Valgus or Hinge Constraint in Primary Total Knee Arthroplasty: Indications and Outcomes of Planned and Unplanned Use.
Clarke ZH, Parks NL, Ray JR, Fricka KB
Topics
Key Takeaway
In 121 primary TKAs requiring varus/valgus or hinge constraint, revision rates were 10% (planned) vs. 6% (unplanned) at mean 6.8-year follow-up with no significant difference in ROM, complications, or PROMs between groups.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study asked whether planned versus unplanned intraoperative use of constrained implants (VVC or rotating hinge) in primary TKA produces different survivorship and functional outcomes. 121 cases from a single high-volume center (2000–2023) were stratified by planned (n=72, driven by severe deformity averaging 9° valgus) versus unplanned (n=46, driven by intraoperative instability with mean 1° varus preoperatively). Revision rates of 10% vs. 6% (p=0.543) and no significant differences in ROM or PROMs were observed between groups.
Key Limitation
Single-center retrospective design with no matched control group of standard primary TKAs limits ability to quantify the true survivorship penalty (or lack thereof) of constraint relative to unconstrained primary TKA.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Varus/valgus constrained and rotating hinge prosthetic designs are occasionally required in primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) to manage major instability. This study evaluated the clinical indications and postoperative outcomes of both planned and unplanned use of constraint in primary TKA.
METHODS
We retrospectively reviewed 121 primary TKA cases that used varus/valgus constraint or hinge prosthetic designs performed between 2000 and 2023 at a high-volume joint arthroplasty center. The mean patient age was 65 years (range, 36 to 90), 78% were women, and the body mass index was 33.2 (range, 16.7 to 55.4). All implants were cemented, and most used stems. Cases were stratified by planned versus unplanned use of constraint. Indications included severe preoperative deformity, iatrogenic medial collateral ligament injury, intraoperative instability, preexisting laxity, poor bone quality, and surgeon discretion. The primary outcomes were revision rates, reasons for revision, ranges of motion, and available patient-reported outcome measures, with a mean follow-up of 6.8 years (range, two to 17).
RESULTS
Planned use (n = 72) was driven by severe deformity (mean 9° valgus), prior trauma, and comorbidities. Unplanned use (n = 46) arose from intraoperative instability and had less severe preoperative alignment (mean of one degree of varus). Revision rates were 10% in the planned group and 6% in the unplanned group (P = 0.543), most commonly due to infection or instability. There were no significant differences observed in ranges of motion, complication rates, or patient-reported outcome measures between the two groups.
CONCLUSIONS
Varus/valgus constrained and hinge prosthetic designs provide effective stability in select primary TKA cases without compromising arthroplasty longevity. Whether planned preoperatively or utilized intraoperatively in response to instability, constrained components demonstrated comparable survivorship and functional results. Preoperative risk assessment can support planning, but intraoperative adaptability remains essential.