JOA - 2026-11-01 - Journal Article
Femoral Bowing in Total Knee Arthroplasty: Angular Deviation as a Primary Mediator of Poor Five-Year Function and Evidence-Based Thresholds for Intervention.
Chen H, Xie P, Yan CH, Chiu KY, Cheung KSC, Cheung A, Fu H
Topics
Key Takeaway
Femoral bowing angle ≥5.9° mediates worse 5-year KOOS primarily through angular resection deviation ≥4.6° (β = -0.356), not through mechanical alignment error alone, in IM-guided TKA.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study examined whether femoral bowing degrades TKA outcomes via resection angular deviation or mechanical malalignment in 422 patients undergoing IM-guided primary TKA. FBA correlated strongly with postoperative angular deviation (r=0.716) and negatively with 5-year KOOS (r=-0.363); mediation analysis confirmed angular deviation—not alignment—as the primary mechanistic pathway (β=-0.356). ROC-derived thresholds of |FBA|=5.9° and |postoperative-Δθ|=4.6° stratified patients with significantly worse pain, sports, daily living, and QoL subscores.
Key Limitation
The study uses a single-institution IM-guided cohort, so findings may not generalize to extramedullary or robotic resection techniques where bowing has a different mechanical impact on cut accuracy.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Femoral bowing compromises intramedullary-guided distal femoral resection accuracy in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), yet its impact on 5-year functional outcomes remains incompletely characterized. This study investigated whether bowing affects TKA outcomes through angular deviation during resection and established clinically actionable thresholds for risk stratification.
METHODS
This study analyzed 422 patients who underwent primary TKA with intramedullary-guided resection with 5-year follow-up. Femoral bowing angle (FBA), postoperative angular deviation of resection (postoperative-Δθ), alignment, and Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Scores were assessed. Pearson's correlation, multivariate linear regression, and mediation analyses evaluated mechanistic pathways, whereas receiver operating characteristic analyses established thresholds. Patients were stratified by thresholds for comparison.
RESULTS
The mean FBA was 1.4 ± 2.9° (range, -5.9 to 11.5), with 6.9% exhibiting severe bowing. The FBA correlated with postoperative-Δθ (r = 0.716) and negatively with 5-year Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Scores (r = -0.363) (both P-values <0.001). Mediation analysis revealed that bowing's impact on improvement in functional outcomes is primarily through postoperative-Δθ (β = -0.356, P < 0.001), rather than mechanical alignment. The thresholds were established: |FBA| = 5.9° and |postoperative-Δθ| = 4.6° (both P-values <0.001). Patients who had severe bowing had worse pain and sports outcomes, whereas those who had unacceptable alignment deviation had worse daily living and quality of life outcomes (all P-values <0.05). Patients who had both severe bowing and unacceptable deviation fared worse across all scales compared to patients who had neither condition (all P-values <0.05).
CONCLUSIONS
Bowing adversely affects TKA functional outcomes primarily through angular deviation during resection rather than through direct effects or alignment alone. The established thresholds provide |FBA| = 5.9° for preoperative risk stratification and |postoperative-Δθ| = 4.6° for intraoperative accuracy objective. For patients who have severe bowing, advanced surgical technologies to enhance resection accuracy may be warranted to optimize functional outcomes.