<- Back to digest

JOA - 2026-11-06 - Journal Article

Comparative Effectiveness of Contemporary Alignment Strategies in Total Knee Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis.

Tan GHC, Lim HA, Thorpe LR, Kon Kam King C, Moo IH

meta-analysisLOE In = 61 studies (22 RCTs, 39 observational), 7,822 patientsN/A

Topics

arthroplasty
PMID: 42994644DOI: 10.1016/j.arth.2026.11.002View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

Functional alignment (MD 14.24, 95% CI 3.32–25.16) and unrestricted kinematic alignment (MD 12.28, 95% CI 9.06–15.51) statistically improved Forgotten Joint Score versus mechanical alignment, but only FA exceeded the minimal clinically important difference threshold, and GRADE certainty was Very Low for most comparisons.

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This systematic review and frequentist network meta-analysis compared uKA, rKA, functional alignment, adjusted MA, and inverse rKA against mechanical alignment using FJS as the primary outcome across 61 studies. FA (MD 14.24), uKA (MD 12.28), and rKA (MD 8.75) all showed statistically significant FJS improvement over MA, but study-design stratification revealed the uKA advantage was substantially larger in observational studies than RCTs (MD 13.76 vs. 7.49). Secondary outcomes (OKS, WOMAC, ROM) were below accepted clinical thresholds, and GRADE certainty was Low to Very Low for all Tier 1 comparisons.

Key Limitation

GRADE certainty was Very Low for most primary comparisons, driven by high heterogeneity and sparse RCT-level direct evidence, meaning the network estimates for FA and uKA are substantially influenced by observational data with inherent selection bias.

Original Abstract

BACKGROUND

Patient-specific alignment strategies are increasingly used in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), but comparative clinical benefit over mechanical alignment (MA) remains uncertain. We compared contemporary alignment strategies using the Forgotten Joint Score (FJS) as the primary outcome.

METHODS

There were four bibliographic databases searched from January 2000 to February 2026 for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and comparative observational studies of primary TKA. Eligible studies compared unrestricted kinematic alignment (uKA), restricted kinematic alignment (rKA), functional alignment (FA), adjusted MA, or inverse restricted kinematic alignment with MA or another strategy. Random-effects pairwise meta-analysis and frequentist network meta-analysis (NMA) were performed to synthesize sparse direct and indirect comparisons across connected alignment strategies. Secondary outcomes were Oxford Knee Score (OKS), Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), and range of motion (ROM)/flexion. Certainty was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) framework. There were 61 studies (22 RCTs, 39 observational; 7,822 patients) that were included.

RESULTS

Compared with MA, FJS improved with FA (mean difference [MD] 14.24, 95% confidence interval [CI] 3.32 to 25.16), uKA (MD 12.28, 95% CI 9.06 to 15.51), and rKA (MD 8.75, 95% CI 3.41 to 14.08). Only FA exceeded the lower FJS minimal clinically important difference threshold, but heterogeneity was high. Study-design stratification reduced several favorable estimates, including the FJS advantage of uKA over MA, which was larger in observational studies than in RCTs (MD 13.76 versus 7.49). The secondary OKS, WOMAC, and ROM/flexion effects were smaller and generally below accepted clinical thresholds. In NMA, FA and uKA ranked highest for FJS in all-study analyses, whereas RCT-only rankings were less decisive. The GRADE certainty was Low for rKA versus MA FJS and Very Low for other Tier 1 comparisons.

CONCLUSION

Contemporary non-mechanical alignment strategies statistically improve FJS after TKA, but clinically meaningful and certain superiority over MA is not established. Longer, adequately powered RCTs are needed before one strategy can be preferred.