Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics - 2026-11-02 - Journal Article
Casting Without Reduction Versus Reduction With or Without Fixation for Mildly Displaced Pediatric Distal Radius Metaphyseal Fractures: A Randomized Noninferiority Trial.
García-Rueda MF, Mendoza-Pulido C, Gil-Laverde JFA
Topics
Key Takeaway
Casting without reduction achieved a mean PROMIS Pediatric Upper Extremity T-score of 45.59 versus 45.62 for reduction under general anesthesia (difference -0.03, 95% CI -4.71 to 4.65), meeting noninferiority at 6 months in children aged 5–10 with mildly displaced distal radius metaphyseal fractures.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This noninferiority RCT asked whether immobilization alone is equivalent to closed reduction under general anesthesia for children aged 5–10 with distal radius metaphyseal fractures with shortening ≤10 mm and/or angulation 10–20 degrees. Sixty children were randomized and 59 completed primary outcome assessment using the PROMIS Pediatric Upper Extremity T-score. Noninferiority was demonstrated with a between-group difference of -0.03 points (95% CI -4.71 to 4.65), and 2 anesthetic-related complications occurred exclusively in the reduction group.
Key Limitation
Follow-up was limited to 6 months, leaving radiographic remodeling trajectories, late deformity, and functional outcomes beyond skeletal maturity uncharacterized.
Original Abstract
OBJECTIVE
To determine whether immobilization without reduction is noninferior to closed reduction under general anesthesia, with or without fixation, with respect to upper-extremity function at 6 months in children with mildly displaced distal radius metaphyseal fractures.
METHODS
We conducted a randomized, open-label, noninferiority trial at a tertiary pediatric orthopaedic hospital. Children aged 5 to 10 years with unilateral mildly displaced distal radius metaphyseal fractures were assigned to immobilization without reduction or closed reduction under general anesthesia, with or without fixation. The primary outcome was the PROMIS Pediatric Upper Extremity T-score at 6 months. The prespecified noninferiority margin was -5 points for the between-group difference.
RESULTS
Sixty children were randomized: 29 to immobilization without reduction and 31 to reduction under general anesthesia. Primary outcome data were available for 59 children. The mean PROMIS scores were 45.59 (SD=9.62) in the immobilization-without-reduction group and 45.62 (SD=8.24) in the reduction-under-anesthesia group. The mean between-group difference was -0.03 points (95% CI: -4.71 to 4.65), meeting the prespecified criterion for noninferiority. No serious adverse events occurred in the immobilization-without-reduction group; 2 anesthetic-related complications occurred in the reduction-under-anesthesia group.
CONCLUSIONS
In children with mildly displaced distal radius metaphyseal fractures, immobilization without reduction was noninferior to reduction under general anesthesia with respect to upper-extremity function at 6 months. These findings suggest that routine reduction under anesthesia may not be necessary in children aged 5 to 10 years with isolated distal radius metaphyseal fractures with shortening ≤10 mm and/or angulation of 10 to 20 degrees.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Level I-randomized controlled trial.