Arthroscopy - 2026-11-05 - Journal Article
Primary Diagnosis, Higher Preoperative Baseline Function, and Female Sex Are Associated With Failure to Achieve the Minimal Clinically Important Difference After Osteochondral Allograft Transplantation in the Knee Among Patients With Intact Grafts: A Multivariable Analysis.
Linstrom NW, Wang T, Bugbee WD
Topics
Key Takeaway
Among 354 knees with intact OCA grafts at minimum 2-year follow-up, 22.6% failed to achieve the MCID for IKDC, with female sex (OR 2.4), fracture etiology (OR 7.4), and higher preoperative IKDC score (4% increased odds per 1-point increase) as independent predictors.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study asked which patient and disease factors predict failure to achieve the MCID (≥11-point IKDC improvement) after OCA transplantation in knees with confirmed graft integrity at minimum 22-month follow-up. Using multivariable logistic regression on a single-surgeon prospective registry (1997–2023), the authors identified primary diagnosis, preoperative IKDC score, and female sex as independent predictors. Fracture etiology carried the highest odds of MCID failure (OR 7.4) versus OCD, while each 1-point higher baseline IKDC score increased failure odds by 4%, reflecting a ceiling-effect phenomenon.
Key Limitation
Exclusion of failed grafts from the analysis introduces survivorship bias, meaning the true rate of clinically meaningful failure across all OCA recipients is underestimated.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
To identify factors independently associated with failure to achieve the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) in International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) total score after osteochondral allograft transplantation in the knee among patients with intact grafts at a minimum of 22-month follow-up.
METHODS
This retrospective cohort study used a prospectively maintained registry of patients who underwent osteochondral allograft transplantation between 1997 and 2023 by a single surgeon. Patients with an intact graft and IKDC score at baseline and a minimum of 22-month postoperative follow-up were included. Failure to achieve the MCID was defined as <11-point increase in IKDC score. Variables significant in univariate analysis were included in a multivariable logistic regression model.
RESULTS
A total of 339 patients (354 knees) were included. The median patient age was 30.4 years and 61% were men. Mean follow-up was 9.4 ± 5.7 years (range: 22 months to 24.4 years). Failure to achieve the MCID occurred in 80 knees (22.6%). Primary diagnosis, higher preoperative IKDC scores, and female sex were significantly associated with increased odds of failing to achieve the MCID. Compared with osteochondritis dissecans, degenerative chondral lesions (2.17 times, P = .036), fracture (7.4 times, P < .001), and osteoarthritis (3.5 times, P = .014) displayed increased odds of failing to achieve the MCID. For each 1-point increase in preoperative IKDC score, the odds of not achieving the MCID increased by 4%. Female patients had 2.4-fold higher odds of failing to achieve the MCID (P = .002).
CONCLUSIONS
Among patients with intact grafts at a minimum of 2 years after osteochondral allograft transplantation in the knee, 22.6% did not achieve the MCID in IKDC total score. The multivariable logistic regression analysis identified primary diagnosis, higher preoperative IKDC scores, and female sex as variables independently associated with decreased likelihood of achieving the MCID.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Level IV, retrospective case series.