JOA - 2026-11-03 - Journal Article; Review
Bayesian Statistics for Arthroplasty Surgeons: Moving Beyond Simple "Yes or No" P-Values to Probabilistic Clinical Decision-Making.
Hoskins W, Gusho C, Parola R, Slobogean G, O'Hara N
Topics
Key Takeaway
Primary prospective Bayesian-designed trials remain rare in orthopaedic arthroplasty; most Bayesian insights derive from post hoc reanalyses of existing frequentist datasets.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This narrative review asks whether Bayesian statistical frameworks offer advantages over frequentist P-value thresholds for interpreting arthroplasty research. The authors introduce Bayes' theorem, contrast frequentist and Bayesian inference, and provide criteria for critically appraising Bayesian arthroplasty studies. The central finding is that binary P-value conclusions are poorly suited to low-frequency arthroplasty outcomes and that Bayesian posterior probability statements better reflect clinical decision-making under uncertainty.
Key Limitation
The narrative format without systematic search methodology limits the comprehensiveness and reproducibility of the evidence synthesis.
Original Abstract
Statistical interpretation underpins evidence-based decision-making in total hip arthroplasty (THA) and total knee arthroplasty (TKA). Traditional frequentist approaches that rely on arbitrary P-value thresholds have long guided research design and analysis in arthroplasty. This approach produces binary conclusions that may overlook clinically meaningful differences, particularly for infrequent outcomes. Bayesian statistics provide a complementary framework that integrates prior knowledge with new evidence to generate probabilistic statements, which align more closely with real-world clinical reasoning. Primary prospective Bayesian-designed research remains rare in orthopaedics. Most Bayesian insights come from post hoc reanalyses of existing frequentist trials. Nevertheless, studies that employ Bayesian methods are increasing. This narrative review introduces core Bayesian principles and Bayes' theorem, illustrates the role of pretest probability in diagnostic testing with practical examples, contrasts frequentist and Bayesian interpretations, and offers criteria for critically appraising Bayesian arthroplasty research.