<- Back to digest

AJSM - 2026-11-05 - Journal Article

Proximal Versus Joint Line Medial Collateral Ligament Trephination (Pie-Crusting): Effects on Meniscal Extrusion and Tibiofemoral Contact Mechanics in a Cadaveric Model.

Abbasian M, Partan M, Korabelnikov T, Patel RR, Chen KM, Moteshakereh SM, Zarei H, Arciero RA

cadavericLOE Vn = 10 cadaveric knees (5 matched pairs)N/A

Topics

sports
PMID: 42989880DOI: 10.1177/03635465261485706View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

Joint line MCL trephination produces significantly greater medial meniscal extrusion and less favorable tibiofemoral contact mechanics than proximal trephination at both 0° and 30° of flexion in a cadaveric model.

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This controlled cadaveric study compared proximal versus joint line MCL trephination (pie-crusting) effects on medial meniscal extrusion and tibiofemoral contact mechanics under 1000-N axial load at 0° and 30° flexion. Both techniques increased medial joint opening and meniscal extrusion versus intact baseline (P≤.05), but joint line trephination produced significantly greater meniscal extrusion at full extension (P=.026) and 30° flexion (P<.001) and greater reduction in contact area at full extension (P=.021). Contact pressure was higher after joint line trephination at both angles, though after adjusting for needle poke count, significance was retained only at full extension (P=.024).

Key Limitation

The sample size of n=5 per group is critically small, limiting statistical power and generalizability, and the cadaveric model cannot account for in vivo capsular healing or the cumulative effect of repeated needle pokes on soft tissue integrity.

Original Abstract

BACKGROUND

Medial collateral ligament (MCL) trephination (ie, "pie-crusting") is used to improve visualization and working space within the medial compartment during knee arthroscopy, but the variability in techniques raises concern for meniscotibial ligament injuries, meniscal extrusion (ME), and altered joint contact mechanics.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effects of proximal versus joint line MCL trephination on ME and knee contact mechanics.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

A total of 10 fresh-frozen cadaveric knees (5 matched pairs) were allocated to 2 groups: proximal trephination and joint line trephination (n = 5 each). Measurements were obtained in the intact condition and repeated after percutaneous MCL trephination. The medial joint opening was assessed arthroscopically and radiographically. Under a 1000-N axial load applied for 30 seconds at 0° and 30° of knee flexion, ME was measured radiographically, and tibiofemoral contact pressure and contact area were recorded using an intra-articular pressure sensor. All statistical analyses were performed using commercial software.

RESULTS

The cadaveric specimens had a mean age of 61.4 years. The joint line group required more needle pokes to achieve adequate release. Both techniques increased the medial joint opening and ME relative to baseline (all P ≤ .05), while no significant changes in contact pressure or area were noted. Contact pressure was higher after joint line trephination at full extension ( P = .018) and 30° of flexion ( P = .035), although after adjusting for the number of needle pokes, a significant difference was only noted at full extension ( P = .024). Compared with proximal trephination, joint line trephination produced greater increases in ME at full extension ( P = .026) and 30° of flexion ( P < .001) as well as a greater decrease in contact area at full extension ( P = .021).

CONCLUSION

When comparing joint line and proximal MCL trephination in a cadaveric model, both techniques increased the medial joint opening and ME; however, joint line trephination caused greater extrusion and less favorable contact mechanics than proximal trephination. Further in vivo studies are needed to determine the clinical relevance of these findings.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This research characterized the biomechanical effects of MCL trephination location on ME and joint contact mechanics. This knowledge supports favoring proximal trephination to limit iatrogenic disruption of the medial compartment.