KSSTA - 2026-11-03 - Journal Article
Kinematic alignment reduces tibial internal rotation and maintains a larger retropatellar contact area than mechanical alignment in early flexion in valgus knees.
Simon JM, Simon F, Siedow TM, Thorwächter C, Traxler H, Bauer L, Holzapfel BM, Müller PE, Niethammer TR, Paulus AC
Topics
Key Takeaway
In cadaveric valgus knees, kinematic alignment produced significantly less tibial internal rotation in early flexion (p=0.011) and a larger retropatellar contact area (p<0.001) compared to mechanical alignment, though neither restored native AP translation.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This cadaveric study compared KA and MA in 10 valgus knees using a dynamic muscle-loaded knee rig from 30°–130° flexion, with each specimen serving as its own native control. KA demonstrated less tibial internal rotation in early flexion (p=0.011), less dynamic valgus deviation in deep flexion (p=0.017), and a larger retropatellar contact area in early flexion (p<0.001) versus MA. No significant differences were found in patellar shift, peak retropatellar pressure, or quadriceps force, and neither alignment condition restored native AP translation kinematics.
Key Limitation
Ten specimens representing only mild-to-moderate valgus limits generalizability to the severe valgus deformities (aHKA >6°) where soft-tissue releases and alignment decisions carry the greatest clinical consequence.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
Alignment effects after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) may be particularly relevant in valgus phenotypes. This study compared kinematic alignment (KA) and mechanical alignment (MA) in valgus cadaveric knees during active, muscle-loaded flexion, using the native knee as reference.
METHODS
Ten fresh-frozen valgus knees (arithmetic hip-knee-ankle angle [aHKA] 0.8°-6.4°) were tested in a dynamic knee rig from 30° to 130° of flexion. Each specimen was assessed sequentially in its native state and after TKA with KA and MA. Tibiofemoral and patellofemoral kinematics were analyzed using one-dimensional statistical non-parametric mapping (SnPM1D) with post hoc paired F-tests, and retropatellar contact mechanics and quadriceps force using paired SPM1D t-tests.
RESULTS
Compared with MA, KA showed less tibial internal rotation during early flexion (p = 0.011) and less dynamic valgus deviation in deep flexion (p = 0.017), as well as a larger early-flexion retropatellar contact area (p < 0.001). Neither condition restored the native anteroposterior translation pattern. Patellar tilt differed between KA and MA (p < 0.001); KA showed greater internal tilt early in flexion and subsequently shifted toward external tilt. No significant differences between KA and MA were detected for patellar shift, peak pressure or quadriceps force.
CONCLUSION
Under these experimental conditions, KA and MA produced distinct rotational, coronal and patellofemoral responses. Similarity to the native reference was outcome- and flexion-dependent. The mild-to-moderate valgus range and the simulated muscle loading preclude conclusions about clinical superiority or the optimal alignment for valgus TKA.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
N/A.