Spine Journal - 2026-11-10 - Journal Article; Review
Reported and Objective Outcome Measures Following Cervical Spine Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.
Carne P, Slosar N, Szerlip N, Bhowmick DA, Kazemi NJ
Topics
Key Takeaway
Across 7 DCM cohorts measuring both modalities in the same patients, reported outcome improvement (SMD up to 2.42 at 12 months) consistently exceeded objectively measured neuromotor recovery in every cohort, with gait SMD only 0.55 at 3 months and balance SMD 0.31 at 6 months.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This PRISMA-guided systematic review and meta-analysis compared responsiveness of reported (PRO and clinician-rated) versus performance-based and instrumented outcome measures at 3, 6, and 12 months after cervical spine surgery for degenerative pathology. Functional scores and pain/disability measures showed large early SMDs (1.36 and 1.16 at 3 months, respectively), while gait improved modestly (SMD 0.55 at 3 months), balance only at 6 months (SMD 0.31), and reaction time did not improve. In all 7 DCM cohorts reporting both modalities, reported improvement exceeded objectively measured improvement, indicating systematic dissociation between perceived and neuromotor recovery.
Key Limitation
The within-cohort dissociation analysis was restricted to only 7 DCM studies, and heterogeneity in the specific objective instruments used across studies limits direct comparison of effect sizes across domains.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND CONTEXT
Cervical spine surgery is increasingly prevalent, yet postoperative outcome assessment varies. Reported outcome measures, both patient- and clinician-rated, are prone to bias, while performance-based and instrumented measures capture functional recovery. How the two relate over the course of recovery is poorly characterized.
PURPOSE
To compare the responsiveness of reported (patient- and clinician-rated) outcome measures with performance-based and instrumented measures at 3, 6, and 12 months following cervical spine surgery across pain/disability, functional scores, balance/posture, gait, reaction time, and motor kinematics, and to test whether reported and objectively measured recovery diverge within the same patients.
STUDY DESIGN
PRISMA-guided systematic review and meta-analysis.
METHODS
PubMed/MEDLINE, Elsevier/Embase, and EBSCO/CINAHL was searched through December 2025, yielding 4,151 records. Eligible studies included adults undergoing surgery for degenerative cervical spine pathology with preoperative and postoperative objective functional data. Standardized mean differences were pooled using three-level random-effects models that account for multiple correlated outcomes within studies. The primary analysis was restricted to degenerative cervical myelopathy cohorts; the full cohort served as a sensitivity analysis. In the studies reporting both modalities, reported and objective recovery were compared within study using paired tests. Quality was assessed using Newcastle-Ottawa Scale and Cochrane Risk of Bias 2.
RESULTS
Twenty studies met inclusion criteria, contributing 267 outcomes. Functional scores improved earliest and most (SMD = 1.36 at 3 months to 2.42 at 12 months), and pain/disability showed large early improvement (1.16 at 3 months). Objective recovery was more modest and domain-specific. Gait improved at 3 months (0.55) with a smaller, less robust effect at 6 months. Balance improved significantly only at 6 months (0.31). Reaction time did not improve. Motor-kinematic outcomes were reported only by non-myelopathic cohorts. Among the seven DCM cohorts measuring both modalities in the same patients, reported improvement exceeded objectively measured improvement in every cohort. Primary and sensitivity estimates were concordant.
CONCLUSION
Following cervical spine surgery, reported recovery, as rated by both patients and clinicians, emerges earlier and with greater magnitude than objectively measured recovery, and within the same cohorts reported improvement consistently exceeds measured improvement. This dissociation indicates that reported recovery alone may overstate neuromotor restoration and it supports continued objective assessment through the first postoperative year. We propose recommendations to standardize longitudinal, dual-modality outcome assessment in cervical spine surgery research.