<- Back to digest

Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics - 2026-11-11 - Journal Article

Development and Validation of a Patient and Caregiver Expectations Survey for Posterior Spinal Fusion for Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis.

Kiani SN, Cazzulino A, Niknam K, Coufal S, Katyal T, Swarup I

prospective cohortLOE IVn = 30 (15 development, 15 validation)One week (test-retest interval for validation phase only)

Topics

pediatricsspine
PMID: 43012752DOI: 10.1097/BPO.0000000000003533View on PubMed ->

Key Takeaway

A validated 10-item preoperative expectations survey for AIS posterior spinal fusion demonstrated moderate-to-great test-retest reliability (patient κ=0.64, guardian κ=0.74), but patient-guardian expectation concordance was poor-to-moderate on most items (κ<0.6).

Summary Depth

Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.

Summary

This study developed and validated separate 10-item Likert-scale expectation surveys for AIS patients and guardians undergoing PSF, using qualitative interviews in 15 dyads followed by test-retest validation in 15 additional dyads one week apart. Guardian surveys achieved substantial-to-great test-retest agreement (κ=0.74) and patient surveys achieved moderate-to-great agreement (κ=0.64). Patient-guardian concordance was great (κ>0.8) on only one item (avoid future medical treatment) and poor-to-moderate (κ<0.6) on the majority of items, indicating systematic expectation misalignment between patients and caregivers.

Key Limitation

The study reports only test-retest reliability without any correlation to actual postoperative PROs, leaving the predictive validity of the survey—its primary clinical justification—entirely unestablished.

Original Abstract

BACKGROUND

Adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS), a condition that can affect body image and psychological well-being, can be treated with posterior spinal fusion (PSF) to prevent later pain and respiratory distress when curves become severe. Efforts have been made to identify factors associated with improved patient-reported outcomes (PROs) after PSF. Across other elective orthopaedic procedures preoperative expectations have been shown to be associated with PROs. A methodical way of measuring expectations is needed to develop methods to modify them and ultimately improve outcomes. The purpose of this study is to develop and validate a survey measuring patient and guardian expectations for PSF in patients with AIS.

METHODS

Patients undergoing PSF for AIS and their guardians were preoperatively interviewed to collect expectations. Qualitative research techniques were used to create two 10-item Likert-scale surveys, one for patients and one for guardians. To validate the surveys, additional patients/guardians completed the survey twice preoperatively a week apart. Cohen quadratic kappa was calculated for each survey item.

RESULTS

A total of 15 patients and guardians were included in the survey development phase and an additional 15 patients and guardians were included in the survey validation phase. The 3 most cited expectations in interviews were return to physical/sporting activities, improvement in pain, and changes in physical appearance. On the validation surveys, guardians had substantial to great agreement (average κ=0.74), and patients had moderate to great agreement (average κ=0.64). Patients and guardians had great agreement with each other (κ>0.8) on only one question-avoid future medical treatment-substantial agreement (κ=0.61 to 0.8) on 2 questions-be more confident in appearance and full recovery without mobility or appearance issues-and poor to moderate agreement (κ<0.6) throughout the rest of the survey.

CONCLUSIONS

It is possible to develop a preoperative expectation survey in patients undergoing PSF for AIS. There is moderate to great agreement between baseline and validation surveys for patients and guardians, but patient and guardian expectations differ. These surveys can help surgeons better counsel families to align expectations and potentially improve outcomes and satisfaction after PSF.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.