JOA - 2026-11-11 - Journal Article
Patient-Reported Outcomes Differ Across Five Contemporary Alignment, Implant and Technology Pathways in Total Knee Arthroplasty.
Lum ZC, Tse S, Lee P, Giordani M, Meehan JP
Topics
Key Takeaway
Restricted kinematic alignment (RR-KA) achieved a mean FJS-12 of 58.0 versus 39.7 for computer-navigated gap-balanced mechanical alignment (CN-GB-MA), an adjusted difference of 18.2 points exceeding the 16.6-point MCID, but each pathway was confounded by surgeon identity.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This single-institution retrospective study compared one-year PROMs across five TKA technique pathways (CN-MR-MA, CN-GB-MA, R-FA, RU-KA, RR-KA) in 1,239 knees using multivariable analysis adjusted for baseline PROM scores. FJS-12 differed significantly across cohorts (P=0.004), with only RR-KA vs CN-GB-MA surviving Holm correction (adjusted difference 18.2 points, 95% CI 8.4–28.1). Generic health measures (PROMIS Global, VR-12) and PASS attainment rates (72.8–82.9%) did not differ across pathways.
Key Limitation
Each of the five technique pathways was performed exclusively by a single surgeon, making surgeon effect, implant type (PS vs CR), and alignment philosophy completely collinear and individually unattributable as drivers of the observed PROM differences.
Original Abstract
INTRODUCTION
Whether technology, alignment philosophy, or balancing strategy yields superior patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) remains uncertain. This study compared one-year PROMs across five technique pathways.
METHODS
From a single-institution PROM database, 1,239 TKAs were grouped as computer-navigated measured-resection mechanical alignment (CN-MR-MA; n = 394), computer-navigated gap-balanced mechanical alignment (CN-GB-MA; n = 365), robotic functional alignment (R-FA; n = 246), robotic unrestricted kinematic alignment (RU-KA; n = 113), or robotic restricted kinematic alignment (RR-KA; n = 121). Each cohort represented one surgeon; navigated cohorts used posterior-stabilized and robotic cohorts with cruciate-retaining implants. The primary outcome was one-year Forgotten Joint Score-12 (FJS-12). Multivariable analyses adjusted for baseline PROM score.
RESULTS
After baseline adjustment, FJS-12 differed significantly across cohorts (P = 0.004), with adjusted means from 39.7 (CN-GB-MA) to 58.0 (RR-KA). Only RR-KA versus CN-GB-MA remained significant after Holm correction (adjusted difference, 18.2 points; 95% confidence interval [CI], 8.4 to 28.1; P = 0.003), exceeding the 16.6-point minimal clinically important difference (MCID), although the interval included smaller values. The Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score for Joint Replacement (KOOS JR) differed on omnibus testing (adjusted P = 0.022) without a significant pairwise contrast. The Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS) Global Health and Veterans RAND-12 (VR-12) scores did not differ. Attainment of the FJS-12 patient-acceptable symptom state was similar across cohorts (72.8 to 82.9%; Holm-adjusted P = 0.902). Expectation fulfillment ranged from 75.6 to 90.5% and patient-reported additional surgery from 0.9 to 5.5%.
CONCLUSION
The joint-specific PROMs differed across pathways, with RR-KA exceeding CN-GB-MA on FJS-12 beyond the MCID, whereas generic measures and threshold attainment were comparable. Because each pathway bundled one surgeon, platform, implant, and philosophy, and no demographic covariates were available, these differences cannot be attributed to alignment strategy. Prospective, covariate-adjusted comparison is required.