JSES - 2026-11-10 - Journal Article
Distal Humerus Nonunion Following Failed Internal Fixation: How do the Outcomes of Internal Fixation and Total Elbow Arthroplasty Compare?
Nieboer M, Yu K, Tangtiphaiboontana J, Barlow J, Morrey M, Sanchez-Sotelo J, O'Driscoll S
Topics
Key Takeaway
For distal humerus nonunion after failed fixation, intra-articular patterns achieve significantly better MEPS with TEA versus S.O.S. (85 vs. 51 points, p<0.01), while extra-articular patterns favor S.O.S. (90 vs. 65 points, p=0.01).
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This single-institution retrospective study compared the S.O.S. technique (humeral shortening, parallel plating, bone grafting) to TEA for distal humerus nonunion after at least one prior fixation failure between 1995 and 2019. Overall complication rates (36% S.O.S. vs. 40% TEA) and MEPS (79 vs. 82) were similar, but subgroup analysis revealed a critical interaction: intra-articular nonunions had 75% reoperation rate with S.O.S. versus 35% with TEA, while extra-articular nonunions achieved superior MEPS with S.O.S. (90 vs. 65, p=0.01). The S.O.S. cohort achieved 84% union rate (21/25), with 2 failures subsequently converted to TEA.
Key Limitation
Non-randomized cohort with systematic age and articular involvement differences between groups makes it impossible to fully disentangle patient selection effects from true treatment effects.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Distal humerus nonunions are difficult to treat. The supracondylar ostectomy and shortening (S.O.S.) technique, which combines humeral shortening, parallel plating, and bone grafting, maximizes the success of internal fixation. The purpose of this study was to compare the outcomes of the S.O.S. technique with the outcomes of total elbow arthroplasty (TEA) for distal humerus nonunions.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This retrospective review identified 25 distal humerus nonunions treated with the S.O.S. procedure and 45 TEA's performed specifically for distal humerus nonunion at a single institution between 1995 and 2019. All elbows had undergone at least 1 prior fixation attempt. The S.O.S. cohort had a younger mean age and less common intra-articular nonunion compared to the TEA cohort. Sex, mean number of prior surgeries, history of open fracture, and history of infection were similar between groups. Outcomes included complications, reoperations, range of motion, and Mayo Elbow Performance Scores (MEPS).
RESULTS
In the SOS cohort, 2 elbows were lost to follow-up, 21 elbows achieved union, and 2 elbows failed to heal and subsequently underwent conversion to a TEA. Complications occurred in 9 elbows (36%) following S.O.S. compared to 18 elbows (40%) following TEA (OR 0.8, p=0.7). The rates of all-cause reoperation were 48% (12 elbows) after S.O.S vs 27% (12) after TEA (OR 2.5, p=0.08). The S.O.S. cohort had a 100° mean flexion-extension arc compared to 115° for TEA (p=0.06) with similar mean pronation-supination arcs (S.O.S. 155° vs TEA 145°, p=0.2). MEPS scores were similar between groups (S.O.S 79 points, TEA 82 points, p=0.6). When stratifying by location of nonunion, elbows with intra-articular nonunion undergoing S.O.S had a 75% reoperation rate compared to 35% for extra-articular nonunions (OR 5.5, p=0.08). Intra-articular nonunions achieved higher MEPS with TEA compared to S.O.S. (85 vs. 51 points, p<0.01) while extra-articular nonunions achieved higher MEPS with S.O.S. compared to TEA (90 vs 65 points, p=0.01).
CONCLUSION
Despite achieving a high union rate, the S.O.S. procedure presented similar results compared to TEA in terms of MEPS, motion, complications, and reoperations. Elbows with an intra-articular nonunion had better outcomes with TEA while elbows with an extra-articular nonunion fared better with the S.O.S.