JSES - 2026-11-09 - Journal Article
Relative Real-time Arthroscopic Evaluation of Glenohumeral Structural Failure during Manipulation under Anesthesia for Primary Frozen Shoulder.
Abdel-Mordy Kandeel A, Lasheen MM, Ali Elsayed AF, Morsi E
Topics
Key Takeaway
Second-look arthroscopy after MUA for frozen shoulder revealed capsular macro-tears in 0% of 31 patients, with motion restoration attributed to adhesion disruption (100%) and capsular stretching rather than gross capsular tearing.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This prospective case series used first- and second-look arthroscopy bracketing MUA in 31 primary frozen shoulder patients to directly visualize post-manipulation structural failure. Second-look arthroscopy confirmed intra-articular adhesion disruption and superior glenohumeral ligament failure in 100% of patients with zero capsular macro-tears; minor structural injuries (SLAP 12.8%, antero-inferior labral detachment 12.8%, PASTA lesion 12.8%) occurred without requiring repair in most cases, while major structural failure requiring repair occurred in 6.4% (one full-thickness rotator cuff tear, one greater tuberosity avulsion fracture). ROM, VAS, and ASES scores all improved significantly at 6 months (P<0.05).
Key Limitation
The 31-patient sample is underpowered to define true incidence rates for low-frequency complications such as greater tuberosity avulsion or full-thickness rotator cuff tear, limiting the reliability of the reported 3.2% figures for each.
Original Abstract
BACKGROUND
Patterns of glenohumeral structural failure during manipulation under anesthesia (MUA) for management of frozen shoulder (FS) have not yet been thoroughly examined. This study investigated the necessity of macroscopic glenohumeral capsular failure/tearing during MUA for motion restoration in patients with primary FS.
METHODS
This prospective case-series study (conducted between November 2023 and May 2025) included 31 patients with primary FS. Patients were managed with 1 st -look arthroscopy (evaluating the integrity of the different glenohumeral structures) followed by MUA, 2 nd -look arthroscopy (documenting the primary outcome of the study; i.e., post-manipulation glenohumeral structural disruptions/failure, especially the capsular tears), and then combined anterior and posterior arthroscopic glenohumeral release. Secondary outcome measurements included immediate post-MUA passive range of motion (ROM), as well as 6-month postoperative (post-MUA and arthroscopic release) ROM and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) scores.
RESULTS
The mean age of included patients was (52.41±11.31) years. 2 nd -look arthroscopy revealed post-manipulation disruption of the intra-articular adhesions and the superior glenohumeral ligament in all (100%) patients; however, no capsular tear was detected in any patient. Otherwise, different glenohumeral structures showed post-manipulation minor failure (not necessitating repair), including superior labrum from anterior to posterior (SLAP) lesion in 4 (12.8%), antero-inferior labral detachment in 4 (12.8%), middle gleno-humeral tear in 3 (9.7%), inferior glenohumeral ligament tear in 1 (3.2%), partial articular-sided supraspinatus tendon avulsion (PASTA) lesion in 4 (12. 8%), and partial subscapularis tear in 3 (9.7%) patients. Major structural failure (necessitating repair) was encountered in 6.4% of the study group, including a full-thickness rotator cuff tear in 1 (3.2%) patient and an avulsion fracture of the greater tuberosity in another (3.2%) patient. There was an immediate post-manipulation significant improvement in passive ROM with further significant improvement on 6-month postoperative evaluation (P-value ˂0.05). In addition, the final postoperative evaluation revealed significant improvement in VAS and ASES scores (P-value ˂0.05).
CONCLUSION
Immediate post-MUA motion restoration in middle-aged patients with primary FS might be attributed to the MUA-induced disruption of the intra-articular adhesions (a consistently encountered finding in this study) and/or capsular stretching out/micro-tears (rather than capsular macro-tears). However, currently reported conclusions should be validated via further larger-volume cohort clinical studies.