Arthroscopy - 2026-11-14 - Journal Article; Review
Systematic Review Reveals Greater Overconstraint in Historic Compared With Recent Biomechanical Studies of Lateral Extra-articular Tenodesis Augmentation of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction.
Nielsen WW, Drake T, O'Malley DL, HoddWells MC, Moatshe G, Geeslin AG
Topics
Key Takeaway
Overconstraint of tibial internal rotation occurred in 67% of recent and 88% of historic LET biomechanical studies, driven by identifiable technical factors including graft tension >20 N, passage superficial to the FCL, tibial external rotation at fixation, and graft width >10 mm.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This systematic review compared historic (1980–2015) and recent (2012–2024) biomechanical studies of LET augmentation to quantify overconstraint rates and identify causative technical factors. Overconstraint of tibial internal rotation was present in 88% of historic versus 67% of recent studies; anterior tibial translation overconstraint was less common (25% historic, 19% recent). Graft passage superficial to the FCL, tension >20 N, tibial external rotation at fixation, and graft width >10 mm were consistently associated with overconstraint.
Key Limitation
All included studies are cadaveric biomechanical models that cannot replicate in vivo soft-tissue healing, graft remodeling, or dynamic neuromuscular loading, limiting direct translation of overconstraint thresholds to clinical outcomes.
Original Abstract
PURPOSE
To perform a comprehensive review of recent and historic biomechanical studies investigating the influence of lateral extra-articular tenodesis on knee kinematics, specifically overconstraint, in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed knees.
METHODS
Historic studies were selected from a systematic review of studies from 1980 to 2015, and an overlapping systematic review of recent studies was performed using the PubMed, Medline, Embase, and Cochrane databases between January 1, 2012, and April 8, 2024. Knee kinematics (tibial translation and rotation) were evaluated for experimental states, including variations of intact, anterior cruciate ligament sectioned, anterior cruciate ligament reconstructed, anterolateral complex sectioned, and lateral extra-articular tenodesis procedures. Overconstraint was defined as reduced tibial translation or rotation compared with the native state.
RESULTS
Twenty-one recent studies were compared with 8 historic studies. Overconstraint occurred in 4 (19%) recent studies and 2 (25%) historic studies testing anterior tibial translation and in 14 (67%) recent studies and 7 (88%) historic studies testing tibial internal rotation. Graft passage superficial to the fibular collateral ligament, increased graft tension at fixation, tibial external rotation during fixation, graft width >10 mm, and intact anterolateral complex were all associated with overconstraint.
CONCLUSIONS
Overconstraint of knee kinematics after lateral extra-articular tenodesis, most notably tibial internal rotation, was associated with technical factors, including graft passage superficial to the fibular collateral ligament, graft tension >20 N, tibial external rotation during graft fixation, graft width >10 mm, and testing with intact anterolateral complex structures. Because of these technical factors, overconstraint was more commonly reported in historic studies compared with recent studies.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE
Avoiding technical factors, including graft passage superficial to the fibular collateral ligament, graft tension >20 N, tibial external rotation during graft fixation, and graft width >10 mm, may minimize the potential for overconstraint.