Spine - 2026-11-15 - Journal Article; Comparative Study
Comparison of the Sagittal Age-Adjusted Score and the T4-L1PA Mismatch in Discriminating Proximal Junctional Kyphosis and Failure in Adult Spinal Deformity Surgery.
Park SJ, Park JS, Kang DH, Lee CS
Topics
Key Takeaway
The T4-L1PA mismatch outperforms the SAAS for discriminating proximal junctional failure (AUC 0.702 vs. 0.503; DeLong P=0.019), while both schemes perform equivalently for PJK in 401 ASD patients.
Summary Depth
Choose how much analysis to show on this article page.
Summary
This study compared the discriminative ability of the SAAS and T4-L1PA mismatch for PJK and PJF in 401 patients (mean age 70, 87% female) undergoing ≥6-level fusion to the pelvis for degenerative ASD. PJK/F occurred in 140 patients (34.9%; 113 PJK, 27 PJF); for PJK, both schemes performed equivalently (DeLong P=0.962), but for PJF the T4-L1PA mismatch was significantly superior (AUC 0.702 vs. 0.503, P=0.019) and added incremental value over clinical risk factors (Δ-2LL 10.8, P=0.001) while the SAAS did not (Δ-2LL 0.3, P=0.580). Component analysis identified L1PA as the driver of PJF discrimination, with the composite T4-L1PA mismatch outperforming L1PA alone.
Key Limitation
PJF occurred in only 27 patients (6.7%), limiting statistical power for subgroup analyses and reducing confidence in the AUC estimates for this critical endpoint.
Original Abstract
STUDY DESIGN
Retrospective single-center study.
OBJECTIVE
To compare the discriminative ability of the sagittal age-adjusted score (SAAS) and the T4-L1PA mismatch for proximal junctional kyphosis (PJK) and proximal junctional failure (PJF) after adult spinal deformity (ASD) surgery.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA
The SAAS and the T4-L1-Hip axis are two contemporary alignment schemes, but no study has directly compared their discriminative ability for proximal junctional complications.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
We analyzed 401 patients (mean age, 70 yr; 87% female) who underwent surgery for degenerative adult spinal deformity with ≥6-vertebrae fusion to the pelvis and two-year follow-up. The SAAS, the T4-L1PA mismatch, and their components were evaluated as continuous variables. Discrimination for PJK/F, PJK, and PJF was assessed by area under the curve (AUC) and compared using the DeLong test. Nested multivariable logistic regression tested the incremental value of each scheme over clinical risk factors, expressed as the change in -2 log likelihood (Δ-2LL).
RESULTS
Proximal junctional complications occurred in 140 patients (34.9%; 113 PJK, 27 PJF). For PJK/F and PJK, the two schemes discriminated comparably (DeLong P =0.401 and 0.962) and both independently improved the adjusted models (SAAS Δ-2LL 4.8 and 5.3; T4-L1PA mismatch Δ-2LL 12.7 and 7.9; all P <0.05). For PJF, the T4-L1PA mismatch was significantly superior (area under the curve: 0.702 vs . 0.503; DeLong P =0.019) and added value in the nested model (Δ-2LL 10.8; P =0.001), whereas the SAAS did not (Δ-2LL 0.3; P =0.580). Component analysis showed that only the PI-LL offset drove the SAAS, while the L1PA was associated with all outcomes; for PJF, the composite T4-L1PA mismatch outperformed the L1PA alone.
CONCLUSIONS
The SAAS and the T4-L1PA mismatch discriminated PJK comparably, but the T4-L1PA mismatch was more discriminative for PJF, although the overall discrimination remained modest. Correcting the lumbar segment addresses PJK, whereas optimal restoration of the T4-to-L1 relationship is additionally required to prevent PJF.